I do recall the experience as a non-status member on QF to be very average - sometimes you don't get your meal choice, service is quite impersonal.
As a WP though, on QF I'll often get the CSM greeting, meal choice before others (sometimes before take off), and a check in from the CSM before landing. PJ's offered in my size pro-actively. However, service is drawn out and often too slow.
Whereas, an airline such as JAL might have above average and consistent service for everyone, but I've found as a OWE that there is no difference in the soft service. No greeting at all, nothing to recognise that I'm a frequent traveler.
And then getting to BA. I've had my meal choice taken and then told later that it's unavailable. Or drinks that never arrive. May as well be in Economy.
