On the fifth attempt over three days (!) I managed to get 2x Upper Class (J) seats JFK-LHR-JFK for next July. I would have preferred to book two separate one-ways but she put it all together and since the previous four agents hadn't been able to even get one flight booked I went ahead.
I was quoted 238000 (59500 pp one-way) + ~AUD1180 total. So far I've been charged the $ but not the points, somehow, yet the itinerary shows as ticketed both with VA and with VS.
Also I think it's meant to be 49500 for that distance (it's ~3540mi, and 59500 band starts at 3600mi) so if they end up charging me I'll petition for the 40k total miles back, but even if it costs the full 240k it's a good deal. JFK-LHR booked a year ago was 49500 + ~AUD50 per person, but obviously there are much higher taxes exUK and the exchange rate has worsened somewhat.
Anyway, tips:
- Check DL or AF for space. They will show fewer options than VS' own website, but the availability lined up better with what the phone agent could actually book.
- Maybe booking roundtrip was the difference? I hope not, and obviously I've booked a VS one-way reward through Velocity in the past, but if you're trying to book what's actually a roundtrip as two separate one-ways, and the agent is striking out for one sector, maybe see if searching for a return itinerary helps?