Ask The Pilot

  • Thread starter Thread starter NM
  • Start date Start date
  • Featured
When, exactly, did you take that picture?

Thanks JB. We'd just arrived from Brisbane on QF51 Sunday night, a bit after 7PM. I think we pulled up at C20, which would place the pictured aircraft in C22, but I could be wrong. I believe it was boarding as QF6 as we were arriving.

I recall reading somewhere (maybe here?) about a flap track fairing disappearing mid-flight, with someone explaining that the biggest drama about it would be whether it had landed on someone. It otherwise operated normally. Being one of the more identifiable characteristics of a 747-400 I guess the absence of the winglet stands out more than anything else. At least it wasn't marked with a friendly "we know about this" like the folks at Alaska did!
 
In this rather simple report which I am sure has many details missing. Is there any reason a landing after and engine fire is more likely to have tyres blow out?

Air Berlin A330 makes emergency landing in coughet after engine fire

Landing with an engine shut down will most likely involve less than normal flap, and a faster approach speed. Couple that with the aircraft being much heavier than usual, and you'll have a lot more energy to get rid of than in a normal landing.

Fuel dump is a customer option, so the ability to quickly get rid of that weight may not have been available.

Whilst a rapid return to the departure airport makes it more likely to blow some tyres, it certainly isn't mandatory....
 
I recall reading somewhere (maybe here?) about a flap track fairing disappearing mid-flight, with someone explaining that the biggest drama about it would be whether it had landed on someone. It otherwise operated normally. Being one of the more identifiable characteristics of a 747-400 I guess the absence of the winglet stands out more than anything else. At least it wasn't marked with a friendly "we know about this" like the folks at Alaska did!

Flap track fairings are basically cosmetic. I think they suffer from cracking on all types, so occasionally they'll be removed by the engineers...to avoid that headache feeling. I lost one on a 767 after a multiple bird strike.
 
Then Merry Christmas to you JB and to all others on AFF lurking these parts to read this message.
May your day be Merry and all your flights be in F!
 
Just snapped VH-OJI in Singapore, and it's clearly missing its right winglet (a Google search turns up much better pics from a few days ago on the yssy forum). Do things like this happen often, and is there much of a performance hit from having a winglet missing?

View attachment 11845

Friends travelled from JNB-SYD on 20 Dec. Plane clipped a glass barrier whilst leaving which caused a seven hour delay. I would suspect this is your bird....
 
Friends travelled from JNB-SYD on 20 Dec. Plane clipped a glass barrier whilst leaving which caused a seven hour delay. I would suspect this is your bird....

Hi JB, I hope you had a great Christmas with your family.
So if that 747-400 flew JNB-SYD with one missing would it have effected performance from a "balance" perspective, both weight and trim?
 
Ask The Pilot

Just reading QF32 which was a nice Christmas gift, came across this photo of Richard doing HUET training, I suspect it's actually the NSCA Facility that was in an industrial estate in Morwell rather than at East Sale, the color scheme of the jet ranger is correct for the time, having been given my first 206 ride with Ray Dousset in what is now the HEMS2 service, I remember it well.

http://www.colacambulance.com/HEMS 2.htm

Straitman??

ImageUploadedByAustFreqFly1356476061.990485.jpg
 
Ask The Pilot

Just reading QF32 which was a nice Christmas gift, came across this photo of Richard doing HUET training, I suspect it's actually the NSCA Facility that was in an industrial estate in Morwell rather than at East Sale, the color scheme of the jet ranger is correct for the time, having been given my first 206 ride with Ray Dousset in what is now the HEMS2 service, I remember it well.

http://www.colacambulance.com/HEMS 2.htm

Straitman??

View attachment 11916
The photo looks like the HUET that the NSCA initially had at Morwell. I only had the good (bad) fortune to use it once.

To the best of my knowledge there never was a HUET at East Sale. From Morwell the NSCA moved their HUET to their West Sale base. After the NSCA folded the TAFE College took over most of the buildings and ESSO bought and took over the running of the Sea Survival (HUET) at West Sale. They still operate the facility today.

I used the West Sale facility many times as we were required to do HUET every three years but Sea Survival annually.
 
Read our AFF credit card guides and start earning more points now.

AFF Supporters can remove this and all advertisements

Amazing how plans change sometimes...I walked through scheduling on Thursday night to sort out a minor issue from a couple of weeks ago, and I was planning to go home to Melbourne on the 10pm flight. Barely arrived and I was asked if I felt like going to Hong Kong today...so now I'm in HK, and head back tomorrow. All of which means I'll have New Year at home too...almost unheard of.
 
Amazing how plans change sometimes...I walked through scheduling on Thursday night to sort out a minor issue from a couple of weeks ago, and I was planning to go home to Melbourne on the 10pm flight. Barely arrived and I was asked if I felt like going to Hong Kong today...so now I'm in HK, and head back tomorrow. All of which means I'll have New Year at home too...almost unheard of.
The rostering gods are smiling on you. :shock: :D :D :D
 
Hey JB, here is a video of some German folk taking an A380 into San Francisco. Do you notice any differences between the way you do things and how they do things that stands out? I found it interesting that the control tower were giving speed commands to the aircraft, I knew they controlled altitude and direction, just not speed.

I found the communication between captain/first officer the most interesting, especially when directions were being passed from the tower to the FO and then to the Captain for a confirmation it seemed?

When the gear down lever is applied, is there a way to actually check that the gear went down that leaves little room for doubt?

It seems difficult for the FO to repeat longer commands given to him by the tower, I noticed sometimes he ends up spurting out half of it - more focused on actually doing what they request instead of clear acknowledgement back to the tower.


Landing SFO San Francisco Airport OnBoard Airbus A380-800 - YouTube
 
Last edited:
Amazing how plans change sometimes...I walked through scheduling on Thursday night to sort out a minor issue from a couple of weeks ago, and I was planning to go home to Melbourne on the 10pm flight. Barely arrived and I was asked if I felt like going to Hong Kong today...so now I'm in HK, and head back tomorrow. All of which means I'll have New Year at home too...almost unheard of.

I think the part that amazes me a bit is the fact that you "walked in" and they asked if you felt like going to Hong Kong today, as if they knew straight away that you'd be in the right state of mind (well, that's not too surprising - the assumption - but also that you could "make it", i.e. not cramming in / exceeding hours etc.).
 
I think the part that amazes me a bit is the fact that you "walked in" and they asked if you felt like going to Hong Kong today, as if they knew straight away that you'd be in the right state of mind (well, that's not too surprising - the assumption - but also that you could "make it", i.e. not cramming in / exceeding hours etc.).

Scheduling know all of those things...
 
Hey JB, here is a video of some German folk taking an A380 into San Francisco. Do you notice any differences between the way you do things and how they do things that stands out? I found it interesting that the control tower were giving speed commands to the aircraft, I knew they controlled altitude and direction, just not speed.

The speed related commands are coming from approach, not the tower. That's normal, but you have to be wary of them, as they've got a nasty habit of leaving you with too much energy.

Procedurally, they're similar, but not identical. The landing checklist was totally different. Curious, as I thought that was the whole point of Airbus...standardisation.

I was curious that the Captain disconnected the autothrust, and flew the approach using manual thrust. The 380 is really meant to have autothrust engaged at all times...there's no reason to disconnect it, as it does a good job.

I found the communication between captain/first officer the most interesting, especially when directions were being passed from the tower to the FO and then to the Captain for a confirmation it seemed?

Fairly standard coughpit comms. Things aren't always clear, and there's sometimes a bit of chat to sort it out.

When the gear down lever is applied, is there a way to actually check that the gear went down that leaves little room for doubt?

Yes...there's no doubt about it. The indication systems are duplicated (different sensors) and it shows up as greens on the dash, and also on the lower display. ECAM will become unhappy if the sequence doesn't complete correctly.

It seems difficult for the FO to repeat longer commands given to him by the tower, I noticed sometimes he ends up spurting out half of it - more focused on actually doing what they request instead of clear acknowledgement back to the tower.

Again pretty normal. He's not doing a bad job, especially as it isn't his native language. The US controllers have habit of speaking pretty quickly, and also of using local terms when speaking to foreign aircraft...and then get cranky when they aren't understood.
 

Become an AFF member!

Join Australian Frequent Flyer (AFF) for free and unlock insider tips, exclusive deals, and global meetups with 65,000+ frequent flyers.

AFF members can also access our Frequent Flyer Training courses, and upgrade to Fast-track your way to expert traveller status and unlock even more exclusive discounts!

AFF forum abbreviations

Wondering about Y, J or any of the other abbreviations used on our forum?

Check out our guide to common AFF acronyms & abbreviations.
Back
Top