Ask The Pilot

  • Thread starter Thread starter NM
  • Start date Start date
  • Featured
Read our AFF credit card guides and start earning more points now.

AFF Supporters can remove this and all advertisements

Should have only been 6 in the circuit as that is the limit for the training circuit at Bankstown, and it might have been me that called :eek:

Has that been in for some time? I know at YMMB that was brought in a few years ago, prior to that I had been in circuits with around 8 aircraft. That was over 10 years ago though.
 
Has that been in for some time? I know at YMMB that was brought in a few years ago, prior to that I had been in circuits with around 8 aircraft. That was over 10 years ago though.

I'd have to check my log book, but I think my first solo flight was in 96.
 
Numbers being called on approach

Hi JB.

Good to see your posts.

In your Youtube videos you're reading off numbers on approach (SYD and LHR). I think that you explained this in aus.aviation, but I don't remember your explanation.

Am I correct, though, in guessing that the FO had the flight while you were monitoring things?

As an aside, must be good not to have the a.a crazies here...

Regards

Martin
 
How is it decided which pilot will be the pilot flying that particular flight considering there is every possibility that a Captain and FO have previously flown on different flights. Is this something that is negotiated between the two pilots, or is it something which is arranged by scheduling.

Also how does the load split between the pilot flying and the pilot not flying. Does the switches which each pilot would normally set remain the same.

An example would be the APU start switch in the B747 is directly over the Captain, assuming this is a switch which the Captain would normally operate, would that remain the same regardless of if the Captain is the PF or the PNF? If the FO is the PF, does the FO give "instruction" (sorry, couldn't think of a better word) to the Captain asking for certain actions to be done? Or are there switches which are only really to be operated by the PF?

Also how much can the PNF do independent of the PF, for example say the FO is the PF, can the Captain (PNF) turn on fuel pumps without specifically been asked by the FO (PF) because it needed to be done, or must the PNF await all instructions from the PF. (Obviously regardless of who the PNF and PF is, if a system mode was changed, there would be a call out stating it has been done to the other pilot)
 
It never seemed to cross anyones' mind that there were a couple of hundred perfectly serviceable radios sitting on the tarmac.

Not sure what you mean by this? Unless, you mean, some aircraft on the ground had a better chance of being a "de facto" ATC rather than one in the air... (though there's still the 'usual suspects' to tend to...)
 
Not sure what you mean by this? Unless, you mean, some aircraft on the ground had a better chance of being a "de facto" ATC rather than one in the air... (though there's still the 'usual suspects' to tend to...)

He means ATC could have simply set up in an aircraft or two as they all have functioning radios.
 
Has that been in for some time? I know at YMMB that was brought in a few years ago, prior to that I had been in circuits with around 8 aircraft. That was over 10 years ago though.

6 was the limit in 89 when I had my tower endorsement at ASBK as it was called then!
 
Another question, can crew announcements \ safety video audio be heard from within the coughpit (even faintly)?
 
Re: Numbers being called on approach

In your Youtube videos you're reading off numbers on approach (SYD and LHR). I think that you explained this in aus.aviation, but I don't remember your explanation.
The numbers are the wind, broken into headwind and lateral components. A 30 knot wind from 30 degrees to the right would be about 29 (on the) nose, and 15 right.

Am I correct, though, in guessing that the FO had the flight while you were monitoring things?
Supporting more than just monitoring. Sometimes it's harder to do the support than it is to do the flying.

As an aside, must be good not to have the a.a crazies here...
It is peaceful, isn't it.

The videos can be found on youtube by searching for user jb380800. I've got some more that I must upload too.
 
He means ATC could have simply set up in an aircraft or two as they all have functioning radios.

Exactly. I really couldn't understand why they didn't, as their radios were down for about 3 hours. It was a really hideous mess.
 
How is it decided which pilot will be the pilot flying that particular flight considering there is every possibility that a Captain and FO have previously flown on different flights. Is this something that is negotiated between the two pilots, or is it something which is arranged by scheduling.
We use lower cross wind limits for the FOs which precludes them operating sometimes, and they also never do the low vis (auto lands). Beyond that, it's totally at the whim of the captain. Scheduling sometimes ask for a sector for a bloke whose recency is running out, but they can only ask. Mostly it's turn about. I've known of captains who never/rarely give a sector away.

Also how does the load split between the pilot flying and the pilot not flying. Does the switches which each pilot would normally set remain the same.
In the Boeing, the FO always did most of the coughpit preflight, with the captain just doing what was on his side, and then checking what had been loaded into the FMC. In the Airbus, most of the coughpit is set up by the pilot flying. Once in the air, autopilot settings are changed by the pilot flying only, whilst most FMC work is done by the non flying. Radio is done by PNF (pilot not flying).

An example would be the APU start switch in the B747 is directly over the Captain, assuming this is a switch which the Captain would normally operate, would that remain the same regardless of if the Captain is the PF or the PNF? If the FO is the PF, does the FO give "instruction" (sorry, couldn't think of a better word) to the Captain asking for certain actions to be done? Or are there switches which are only really to be operated by the PF?
APU start after landing is done by the PNF. Before the flight, generally by the FO. The pilot flying, if hand flying, will call for MCP (mode control panel) changes otherwise he alone makes them. Configuration changes are made by the PNF as called for by the PF. So, basically, the only things that are always done by the Capt or FO relate to switches associated with their displays. Pretty much everything else swaps from side to side depending upon who is flying.

Also how much can the PNF do independent of the PF, for example say the FO is the PF, can the Captain (PNF) turn on fuel pumps without specifically been asked by the FO (PF) because it needed to be done, or must the PNF await all instructions from the PF. (Obviously regardless of who the PNF and PF is, if a system mode was changed, there would be a call out stating it has been done to the other pilot)
Items such as fuel pumps are covered in the preflight checklist and are done exactly in order, by the specified pilot. About the only things that are done by first bloke into the seats is to initiate the download of the flight plan, and to realign the inertial navs. Both occur in the checklist but they take time and it's better to have them done asap.
 
Ditto to previous sentiments! - As I said earlier you should write (spelling corrected!) a book.

In relation to your videos on YouTube, you stated in an earlier post that you were not in control, you were supporting, but I am assuming you were PIC.

In all the vid's the centre line of the runway seems to be under the left side. I would have thought that would have been more towards the centre of the AC or even over to the FO side as he is in control, and would cause bias towards his side. Or is it just a camera angle/location I am not taking into account?:confused:

Thanks in advance.
 
In all the vid's the centre line of the runway seems to be under the left side. I would have thought that would have been more towards the centre of the AC or even over to the FO side as he is in control, and would cause bias towards his side. Or is it just a camera angle/location I am not taking into account?

Remember that I'm filming from the left side. You're about 3 stories up in the air, so it's actually quite difficult to judge exactly, until you get used to the view. The 380 is pretty well exactly on the centreline. The London landing touches down a couple of metres right, and then is quickly fixed. The Sydney landing is in a crosswind. A bit of drift is still there at touchdown (a quite normal technique in the 747), so the main gear is on the centreline, and the coughpit is offset a bit.
 
The 380 is pretty well exactly on the centreline. The London landing touches down a couple of metres right

An aviation magazine, it might've been Australian Aviation, used to have a section called "On the Airwaves". Contributors would send in humorous anecdotes of things that their heard on their scanners, or pilots listening to normal radio chatter.

One of them concerned an exchange between ATC and a BA aircraft which just landed. The ATC fellow congratulated the captain for a great landing, saying that he was "just left" of the centreline.

The BA captain replied, "thanks. And my first officer was just right of the centreline"...
 
Hi JB thanks heaps this has been a great read.

I have noticed a few posts about you not recommending people join the aviation industry as it isn't what it used to be. Could you possibly expand on this a bit please? what made you want to be a pilot and what do you think is required to inspire young ones ( like me, although i like my current job :) to head down this very substantial career path?

And from a pilots perspective what would you tell the people (whoever they are) if they were about to design and build a brand new airport ?
 
An aviation magazine, it might've been Australian Aviation, used to have a section called "On the Airwaves". Contributors would send in humorous anecdotes of things that their heard on their scanners, or pilots listening to normal radio chatter.

One of them concerned an exchange between ATC and a BA aircraft which just landed. The ATC fellow congratulated the captain for a great landing, saying that he was "just left" of the centreline.

The BA captain replied, "thanks. And my first officer was just right of the centreline"...

Nigel is always quick with a reply...though I always thought that most of those AA stories were apocryphal.
 

Become an AFF member!

Join Australian Frequent Flyer (AFF) for free and unlock insider tips, exclusive deals, and global meetups with 65,000+ frequent flyers.

AFF members can also access our Frequent Flyer Training courses, and upgrade to Fast-track your way to expert traveller status and unlock even more exclusive discounts!

AFF forum abbreviations

Wondering about Y, J or any of the other abbreviations used on our forum?

Check out our guide to common AFF acronyms & abbreviations.
Back
Top