I'm not sure where you get the chummy with the labour bit from, certainly it isn't from the labour itself. The line I hear is nobody liked Geoff Dixon until Alan Joyce turned up.
It seems that the 'Sky is falling' brigade is once again in the ascendancy over VA Mk II's future.
Hopefully they will be as correct as their previous predictions, a bit like how economists have predicted nine of the last 2 recessions....
Remember that AJ tried out & perfected all of his 'creative management & accounting' at JQ - such as returning aircraft to Q just before they were due a major check & maintenance etc. Running a slimmed down VA without dreams of becoming all things to all people while having to obey the law according to Bain - does not require a genius.
VA Mk II now has the lowest cost planes of any airlines operating in or flying to Australia, it also has the lowest cost office & airport leases, simplest & quite new fleet. Wage costs are going to be less than Q - possibly by more than the unions want but vs JobSeeker it is a rock & a hard place decision.
VA does not need to operate many routes to be profitable but it does need a decent product to differentiate it. Around 60% (or more) of VA's revenue came from operating the Sydney/Melbourne/Brisbane triangle. At an educated guess around 25 city pairs never did better than operating cost break even - most lost money. Other city pairs only just covered all-in costs due to subsidies for serving some regional centres.
VA Mk II does not aspire to be mini-Q.
Bain's only pay day comes from increasing the value of VFF & has already began making it a much more seamless proposition with VA through web site changes. International trips are a given to optimise VFF's value, no argument. So is a full-service not LCC domestic airline.
VFF has over 10 million accounts, big data is where the money is - just ask Google or Facebook. This is Bain's endgame with a virtually free domestic airline thrown in on the side. Remember VFF stated that all its outstanding points were cash backed bar the loan to VA. So whilst Bain has paid out or agreed to absord some outstanding liabilities (employee entitlements etc) - it has paid under $4bn to get a business with around $1.5bn in cash.
So despite may detractors keen to predict VA's demise since March - the current situation is as far from their predictions as almost possible.
BTW - digging into VA's Annual Reports going back some years was quite revealing about PS. Judging by his total remuneration (salary + bonus) he was not highly valued by either the Board or JB - he seemed to be the lowest paid of the senior executive team - whether warranted or not. Definitely knew how to market himself externally but it can always be dangerous if you start believing your own PR too much.
VA had been quite poor in pulling value out of their 10m+ VFF accounts compared with what Q makes per account (13m). If Bain can improve it to around 60% of what Q achieves then that would double VFF's value. That golden goose requires a domestic full service airline, covering 70% or so (IMHO) of domestic flights taken, to be successful.