Early Check In and late Check Out is one of my constant concerns.
With so many airports now operating 24 hours and most long-haul flights being overnight for maximum aircraft utilisation, a frequent traveller is always arriving first thing or departing around mid-night. I have tried to use the options mentioned above and have had some success with a number of the strategies However, I do think there should be other published options, especially in regions where the availability and cost of having 24-hour housekeeping staff available makes this a realistic possibility.
While appreciating the need for hotels to maximise revenues from high occupancy, I believe there should be the option available to help the traveller who only wants to drop bags, have a shower, answer emails and maybe get some breakfast before heading out. Similarly, I have often had to 'beg' and pay a late check-out even with loyalty at the Hotel. How often have you heard: 'We can give you a 1800 checkout for only 50% of the daily rate'? As if that is much help when you have a flight departing after mid-night.
I vividly remember arriving at a hotel in Mumbai around 0300 a few years ago with a confirmed booking for that night and having to wait an hour while they cleaned the room vacated by a guest who told me he had also paid a full night's rate and was checking out just at I arrived. A classic case of double dipping.
Some hotels are better than others, realising that many guests will arrive early but others leave before 0600 so having early housekeeping available is real service delivery they can offer. I'd be more than happy to have a published half-day (12 hour) rate for early arrival or late check out and I am always happy (within reason) to accept any room if I need a sleep urgently (as I do not sleep well on planes). I would be happy to accept access to the health club for a shower and breakfast as well if I have early appointments.
I also believe more hotels should look at the 24-hour option - like rent-a-cars - even with a premium.