Finally accommodation in Port Douglas was the Sheraton Mirage. Decision was easy since the Pullman there was totally booked out. We booked a garden view studio room.
Firstly, if you need a room to be dark to sleep, this hotel is not for you. There are no block out curtains. They have wooden slats there slide closed but are at a fixed angle and not completely closed. I was pretty shocked when I realised this. I would have moved hotels if there were options, but there weren't.
We had a bunch of small issues with this hotel. The pool and common areas are stunning. The rooms are tired and desperately in need of maintenance. The first room we were in there was silicon missing from the window. The second one the sliding door was really rough. Hot water was only warm (wasn't a show stopped and fixed on day 3). It's clear staff are aware of these problems. House keeping was also hit and miss. Each day there was something small they forgot. No coffee pods, no pool towels, etc.
The hotel loyalty manager, to his credit, did a pretty decent job of service recovery. On the last day was had a great cheese platter and some wine left in the room. I don't think it was a coincidence that our table at Harrisons was the best table in the house. Sufficient Bonvoy points for two free nights have also been promised.
Also as a Bonvoy gold I got to select from a lucky dip of prizes at check-in. Ours was 20% off F&B at all restaurants except the pool and room service. Great in theory, except getting a table at the restaurants was near on impossible. Also, between 4-5pm there was a happy hour for Bonvoy members in the Daintree Bar, which was a lovely spot when it wasn't full of kids (ok, happened one night).
All in all, I'd check out the Pullman if I were to return to the area. I did stick my head in. The pool area doesn't look as nice though but hardly terrible. Unless the lack of block out blinds is resolved, I wouldn't return to this hotel.
Our room had good privacy. Level three at the north end looking onto gardens and the golf course. Rooms onto the pools really lack privacy. At night you can see straight in with the lights on. Even the sheer curtain doesn't really help. Rooms onto the smaller lagoon pools would be more privacy, but again you have walk ways to access different area.