I would suggest that those that have the opinion that the SCs will be applied to the membership year in which the points were accrued are incorrect. It's an opinion only, with no evidence to back it. For the benefit of others following I would not post this opinion again.
I would say that people should be free to post whatever opinions they like.. Everyone has one. That's my opinion
On topic, every other single instance of such things have always related to the year they were earned. I mean, for example, if you fly a flight on Dec 29, your membership year rolls over on Dec 31, but the flight posts on Jan 2nd, its points and SC's apply to the prior membership year. The LB is earned in the membership year so any bonus SC's earn should also, by logic, and common practice, apply to that year also.
Having written that, of course, it's up to QF how they wish to apply this specific bonus and if they want to be different that's totally fine.
As further evidence I've also just selected to have 50 SCs applied to my new membership year that started on the 1st January. The Loyalty Bonus was gained in November last year. Made a call to QFF to confirm.
Can you explain this statement further? How does one "select to have 50 SC applied to my new membership year"? Or are you suggesting that you simply made the selection of the LB post your new membership year starting, but within the 90 day window to make a choice?
Are you also suggesting that QFF confirmed that, selection having been made in your new membership year, that these SC's apply to this year, rather than last?
if so, that's great for you. I can see a number of issues with this approach, both positive and negative depending on one's perspective, but at the end of the day it's absolutely up to QF how they apply this.
I still think (yes, it's MY opinion
) that this behaviour is not how QFF would have intended the LB SC's to apply - if so I think they would have specifically stated it. It certainly provides some incentive to accrue a LB in the last month or two of one's membership year to get a (small) leg up for the next. If this is what QFF intended, you'd imagine they'd have advertised this as such.
Again, just my opinion