To summarise. I'll also ask
@Port Power to do similar (no need to go into so much detail!!) , if they wish, as I think getting an experienced cruiser's thoughts Vs mine will be a good balance.
Itinerary: 10/10 Totally met my expectations and hopes. The Captain and Expedition Leader seems to have delivered great outcomes in response to changing weather (although we were blessed with great weather on many days). Bird flu limited a few things on Sth Georgia but we saw plenty of penguins and seals anyway!! Zodiac drive-bys gave much the same experience. I would not recommend missing the Falklands and doing Sth Georgia should eb a must. Those just going straight down to Antarctica and back are doing themselves a disservice, I think.
Vessel: Silver Wind. It worked for me in respect of layout and facilities. A little big for what would be ideal on an expedition ship - a limit of 200 would be good, given the ship size. Captain was fantastic in interaction with passengers and efforts to get us close to icebergs (
). The retro fitted Wind and Cloud have an Achilles heel in that if their side doors (where the zodiac dock is create) is damaged by ice drifting by, its actually "abandon ship", as the vessel is no longer watertight. Ships with docks/marinas at the stern much better (like the Silver Endeavour and Ponant's Le Laperouse that I was on last year).
Classic verandah suite, deck 5. Worked for me. Lay-out is effective and I didn't have any issues. I wondered how a veranda would go on an Antarctic Cruise but I used it frequently and it added much to the experience. Deck 5 was handy to most frequently-used facilities. I think the concept of a 'butler' is a bit silly, but as a guy to bring things and arrange things, it worked well. He soon learned my fondness for an afternoon G&T and made sure there was citrus and ice in the fridge all the time. The room attendant worked hard and again, learned how I like things to be made up and arranged.
Ship restaurants and bars. The quality of the food was excellent. Enough menu variation so that repetition not an issue. I maintain my criticism of the performance of
some of the wait staff. Just not experienced enough to be present on a SilverSea cruise. The maître d's were very good - soon learned my name and seating preferences. The quality of the included wines was good - a selection from around the world and there was only one or two that I wouldn't try a second time. I thought it annoying that they didn't have a list of these wines, given that you could ask for any at any meal, not just the white and red on offer that meal, but I understand that's a SS standard.
Expedition crew: Its a big team!! I've expressed some criticisms in the TR, and on reflection I stand by them, but I admit that I have quite a bit of science behind me (not just geology) and my expectations may have been a bit high; again, I'm not just talking about geology. They have a standard patter suitable for persons in the street and seemed to struggle to go beyond that. They were all good with their zodiacs and safety was never in doubt and I was never concerned about that. A major fail was not having a proper debrief after and about a day's activities. I saw the exped leader early on and mentioned that this would be a good thing to do, and he actually promised it, but it didn't eventuate.
Social activities, spa etc. I was usually too tired to engage in the evening social activities and the spa was never on my agenda. But what I did see of the socials was very good - the 'social director' seemed very good; perfect for the job. There were 8-10 of us 'solos' who mixed & matched in dining and other activities; worked well.
Pre and post. This cruise involved a pre and post hotel night, and a 4 hour charter flight to and from Puerto Williams. On 'changeover days' that have 200+ people checking out, and chartering down and the same number chartering back and checking in. A big logistical exercise. The charter flights were excellent - good aircraft, seating density was comfortable, v good leg room and the food and bev was good. Business class. The hotel, the Mandarin Oriental, which I think has a A$650+ rack-rate was disappointing in some regards. Room was good.
SilverSea. A SS cruise was a cost-stretch for me, and I regarded it as the equivalent of buying a First Class ticket. I suspect that my expectations were a bit high and should take account that the explosion in expedition cruising and demand for crew and staff. I'm not yet a SS die-hard (considering the price).
So, is that all a bit whiney ... should I just sit back and loved the cruise? Yes, maybe, but if SS put themselves out as being a luxury experience, it should be ticking all the boxes. I have a SS Caribbean cruise booked for next Christmas; 'classic' cruise on the Silver Muse. See how that goes
. Then I want to go to the Arctic in mid 2025; I want to do Greenland and Svalbard; no coastal Iceland and mainland Norway only as necessary. SS don't have that itinerary, so I'm on the hunt for a cruise.