Hey all! Thought I'd weigh in on this topic seeings as how I've had very recent and still continuing experience that may be of interest.
My particular story is as follows. My partner and I have made plans to visit the US in March next year for about three weeks for our annual OS trip. As with anyone we both applied for the VWP and she was lucky enough to be issued through. I unfortunately was asked to attend the Melbourne consulate as a result of a minor shoplifting(stealing under crimes of moral turpitude)offence that took place when I was 17(tried as adult) which occured nearly 18 years ago. As has happened to others here I was denied upon the day of the interview but had an ineligibility waiver application lodged to the DHS in the States. Upon leaving the consulate I was really left with no clearer clue as to what would happen in the 4-8 weeks time stated on the 1 form I was given for my troubles.
After collecting my thoughts on the whole episode I re-read the form and the only guide I could get was when it stated'In general, DHS views recent and/or multiple convictions unfavourably.' Going by this I would confidently consider myself home free as the offence was a once off and was by no means recent but honestly who knows??
Its lucky for us that I've always wanted to go to the US at least once in my life as to be frank to have to go though all this hassle for a simple holiday would not really of been worth it.
I'd love to hear more thoughts and experiences and will keep you posted as to the end result...... A postive one I hope??
I'm 99.9% sure you will not have any issues at all. Seeing as though it was so long ago. They mainly look at the severity of the offence/s and the length of time that has passed.