Dan Murphy's and Other Wine Deals

[olympicwiz]

I only bought it because of the $50 price tag…

$50 for this box .. now this is what I would call THE bargain!

 

[mrak]

Oh well. Guess I still get wine. View attachment 252501

95 Sam Kim paid points. Not available online from VC. Must have used it all to fill Haselgrove orders. I was thinking it would be the next $5 special

 

[Steady]

$50 for this box .. now this is what I would call THE bargain!

Sorry, $50 a bottle for these 6 as posted up thread….

(not very good compared to the 3 I already had in my cellar @ $20.52 a bottle ….)

 

[roshea]

VC also offered me the $40 Pertaringa in place of the Haselgrove Protector, but the last 3 vintages of that all scored only 86 from Halliday, so that's a no from me! Hopefully the Catkin will still come, no official word on that yet.

 

[chylee]

Oh well. Guess I still get wine. View attachment 252501

I got offered replacements with Chateau Tanunda 50yo Vines instead. Not sure if they are any good but for $5 each I accepted.

 

[blackcat20]

I got offered replacements with Chateau Tanunda 50yo Vines instead. Not sure if they are any good but for $5 each I accepted.

I've been offered those as well.

 

[olympicwiz]

VC also offered me the $40 Pertaringa in place of the Haselgrove Protector, but the last 3 vintages of that all scored only 86 from Halliday, so that's a no from me!

So you would rather have a refund of $5 than to accept Pertaringa?

 

[chonka]

So you would rather have a refund of $5 than to accept Pertaringa?

I've had plenty of decent wines that JH rated low. Pertaringa wines have always been decent wines in my books.

 

[Tannin]

I got offered replacements with Chateau Tanunda 50yo Vines instead. Not sure if they are any good but for $5 each I accepted.

It retails at $80 so I think you'll be fine.

 

[roshea]

So you would rather have a refund of $5 than to accept Pertaringa?

Yes, it's not a wine I would choose to buy and the RRP is meaningless to me if the wine is not good.

 

[olympicwiz]

I've had plenty of decent wines that JH rated low. Pertaringa wines have always been decent wines in my books.

Agreed 100% I rarely pay any attention to JH ratings unless it is a Margaret River CS. Pertaringa is a good brand and $5 is a steal for that cab.

 

[olympicwiz]

Yes, it's not a wine I would choose to buy and the RRP is meaningless to me if the wine is not good.

It’s fair enough. I just think solely deciding that the wine is bad on a JH rating is a mistake.

Many more great deals to come along I am sure!

 

[kevviek]

It’s fair enough. I just think solely deciding that the wine is bad on a JH rating is a mistake.

Many more great deals to come along I am sure!

I’d be happy to take them off your hands for $5ea!

 

[olympicwiz]

I’d be happy to take them off your hands for $5ea!

I would pay $10 as I am a bit partial to Pertaringa personally

 

[misohoney]

$10.10 as I am a bit partial to outbidding OW

 

[year of the roo]

Do I hear $10.20?

 

[Simmosp1]

So I'm getting a dozen (I hope) replacement Pertaringa from VC. But I still have the haselgrove in my cart I'm wondering if I should pull the trigger on another case to see what I get, like a lucky dip...

 

[olympicwiz]

So I'm getting a dozen (I hope) replacement Pertaringa from VC. But I still have the haselgrove in my cart I'm wondering if I should pull the trigger on another case to see what I get, like a lucky dip...

If you are able, it makes sense .. like a free option to choose .. either a replacement or cash back

Post automatically merged: Jul 9, 2021

Do I hear $10.20?

I will go 10.11

 

[chonka]

Do I hear $10.20?

@chonka checks shopback and cashrewards before decision

 

[kevviek]

So I'm getting a dozen (I hope) replacement Pertaringa from VC. But I still have the haselgrove in my cart I'm wondering if I should pull the trigger on another case to see what I get, like a lucky dip...

I could never find them on the site, curious how they could still be in you cart. Catkin is $92/btl at Dans https://www.danmurphys.com.au/produ...CSH750ML/haselgrove-origin-catkin-shiraz-2015