Elite treatment at Hilton Surfers Paradise

Status
Not open for further replies.
Re: How do Hilton treat you as an Elite?

You must have felt so superior, you are lucky I wasn't within earshot

Are we still on that topic?
I felt ripped off for dining in a 5* hotel and getting a 3* treatment from a chef that was too lazy to do his job.

I stay almost every week at a Hilton property and the service is usually great.
HSP has a lot to improve to be on par with the rest.
 
Re: How do Hilton treat you as an Elite?

Can anyone confirm if this is still happening at HSP ? I'm staying there in early sept....

Are we still on that topic?
I felt ripped off for dining in a 5* hotel and getting a 3* treatment from a chef that was too lazy to do his job.

I stay almost every week at a Hilton property and the service is usually great.
HSP has a lot to improve to be on par with the rest.
 
Re: How do Hilton treat you as an Elite?

I sort of get your drift (dig your drift, man.....if I were 10 years older) but surely boomy has a point. The HSP was most definitely marketed pre-opening as a 5* hotel, but the experience if far from it. Is he/she wrong to expect basic requests to be able to be supplied. Expecting the customer to do-their-own is not what I would expect if paying $35-$40 for a breakfast and the staff should be able to fill such orders. Many people do that themselves at home so what's the deal with "here's the basics....you assemble"....it's not IKEA!

I completely agree swanning it, my issue was with the proclamation to the chef that they shouldnt be working in a 5 * hotel, I woud have been thinking exactly the same thing as boomy at that comment from the chef to assemble it, but would have taken my feedback and given it to management rather than taking my frustration out on the person right in front of me who has no say in the policy of the hotel which is obviously not to give eggs benedict.
 
Re: How do Hilton treat you as an Elite?

the policy of the hotel which is obviously not to give eggs benedict.

I must be very lucky then, because all the Hiltons in Australia (include HSP before that incident) are breaking the "policy" just for me every single time.
 
Re: How do Hilton treat you as an Elite?

I must be very lucky then, because all the Hiltons in Australia (include HSP before that incident) are breaking the "policy" just for me every single time.

Note it does say hotel, not hotel chain.
 
Read our AFF credit card guides and start earning more points now.

AFF Supporters can remove this and all advertisements

We stayed last night at HSP. The first stay since the abysmal effort of last January.

The conclusion? Staying in the hotel part is better than the residences as you're guaranteed the Orchid Tower and basically 3 elevators just for the hotel floors which means minimal waiting. I'm bouyed by the stay generally and will return on that basis (even booked more stays while we were there), but it's on the sad understanding the exec lounge is better off being left alone and instead we'll be having predinner drinks at one of the many Irish bars in the near vicinity!

It's fair to say we had some wins and some losses.

Booked a King Guest Room for 1A, 1C and used the "HHonors Benefit - Spouse Stays Free - Occupancy 2A,1C" wording which turned out as I hoped, 1 King Bed and a trundle for our daughter whilst still retaining the standard rate (a trundle is normally $60, so this method of booking was a nice saving). We were also upgraded to a King Relaxation Room so there was plenty of space and the relaxation room was really a very pleasant room (huge desk which suited as I had work to do while I was there). Received the GM card (new GM by the looks of it), the fruit platter and two large bottle of water (one still, one sparkling) and at turn down, received a further two 500ml bottles of water and 3 chocolates. Internet provided free with no billing issues, but didn't receive either the morning paper or our quick check-out bill under the door. Early check-in was denied but a 2pm late check-out was granted. Had to call for the trundle bed and the TV had a problem but both were rectified promply. Breakfast was complementary for all three of us in Salt Grill and was OK (eggs benedict were deconstructed and consisted of two poached eggs and a side of Hollandaise sauce with no ham/bacon or muffins.....get your own I guess). All in all, I was very plesantly surprised at how well it all went and I did very much appreciate the upgrade and complementary trundle bed.

Now to the gripes (come on, surely you knew I'd have some gripes ;))! I didn't actually believe the executive Lounge could sink any lower than the stay we had where the only food offering for afternoon tea was the left over breakfast stuff (at 3pm), but I think this stay rivaled that :shock:.

At least at afternoon tea, there was one cake and some biscuits that were fresh. However we arrived at about 3.05 and there was no milk in the coffee machine, no one on duty in the lounge and the used coffee capsule drawer was full as well, which meant our much anticipated coffee was just not happening. I would have thought prior to an anticipated influx of guests, such things would have been checked and fully prepared, but anyway, the lady was along in due course and we did end up with our coffees and cake. Hooray!

After a lovely walk along the esplanade and a "window" shop through the Sunday night market stalls, we ambled back to the room to prepare for 6pm canapes and drinks. We arrived at 6.20 to be advised by the only attendant that most of it was finished :shock:.....at 6.20! The hot food was not just finished, but gone and cleaned up, the tired old antipasta spread had no meat selection left at all, the breads looked like what was left after a herd of rats had finished, there were bread sticks but virtually no crackers and it appeared no cheeses had made it out at all, which left the only offering being pumpkin soup and a bowl of jelly beans! Now I've seen some bloody ordinary offerings here at HSP over their short history, but never had I seen such a ratty display of leftovers! The lounge was also partitioned off with storage of sorts happening in the eastern area which also meant the balcony was not accessible (there was no function) and although the lounge was not full, there were still a good 30 - 35 people there, so not empty either. There was a mix of disbelief, mild amusement and utter dispair amongst the guests and the high quality aura was assisted by the rugby being on at volume with no body watching it????

I asked to speak to the lounge manager. The lounge manager had the week-end off. What's that? Surely they have shift supervisors or something, but fortunately the sole male attendant (who was without doubt, well over his head) was joined by a very capable lady from Salt who quickly organised for a hotel duty manager to come up and address the situation. She was alarmed at what she found and proceded to organise more hot food to be brought up from Salt, more wine to be brought out (the few bottles were almost finished), the cheeses to be brought out, the meats to be restocked but despite this excellent recovery from two very talented ladies, one has to ask how could Hilton allow that to happen? Even with the sterling efforts of those two it remained comical to closing time with breads being brought out without a breadknife, forks running out, glasses running out, no crackers for the cheese, no serviettes and no ladels for the rushed out pasta dishes. I took a few photos below at 6.30, but remember we arrived to nothing at 6.20. It took me ten minutes to get over my disbelief and get my phone out. HSP continues to have the exec lounge with the nicest view and the worst food and service.

Antipasta.jpg
The meat dishes!

Bread.jpg
The breads (note the vast selection of cheeses....not)

Hot food.jpg
The hot food selection (note there were three pieces of fruit on offer)

Clean plate.jpg
And for good measure.....a filthy plate!
 
That's absolutely woeful :eek:
I kept expecting to see a pic of Basil Fawlty and the Waldorf salad.
I would definitely contact Hilton corporate regarding the unacceptable service levels in the Exec lounge. One of the major benefits of HH Diamond is Executive Lounge access with an expectation of reasonable F&B as advertised by each property.
Kudos to the staff who tried to make amends but seriously after reading of your stay I wouldn't be tempted to give them any of my business.
 
We stayed last night at HSP. The first stay since the abysmal effort of last January.

The conclusion? Staying in the hotel part is better than the residences as you're guaranteed the Orchid Tower and basically 3 elevators just for the hotel floors which means minimal waiting. I'm bouyed by the stay generally and will return on that basis (even booked more stays while we were there), but it's on the sad understanding the exec lounge is better off being left alone and instead we'll be having predinner drinks at one of the many Irish bars in the near vicinity!

It's fair to say we had some wins and some losses.

Booked a King Guest Room for 1A, 1C and used the "HHonors Benefit - Spouse Stays Free - Occupancy 2A,1C" wording which turned out as I hoped, 1 King Bed and a trundle for our daughter whilst still retaining the standard rate (a trundle is normally $60, so this method of booking was a nice saving). We were also upgraded to a King Relaxation Room so there was plenty of space and the relaxation room was really a very pleasant room (huge desk which suited as I had work to do while I was there). Received the GM card (new GM by the looks of it), the fruit platter and two large bottle of water (one still, one sparkling) and at turn down, received a further two 500ml bottles of water and 3 chocolates. Internet provided free with no billing issues, but didn't receive either the morning paper or our quick check-out bill under the door. Early check-in was denied but a 2pm late check-out was granted. Had to call for the trundle bed and the TV had a problem but both were rectified promply. Breakfast was complementary for all three of us in Salt Grill and was OK (eggs benedict were deconstructed and consisted of two poached eggs and a side of Hollandaise sauce with no ham/bacon or muffins.....get your own I guess). All in all, I was very plesantly surprised at how well it all went and I did very much appreciate the upgrade and complementary trundle bed.

Now to the gripes (come on, surely you knew I'd have some gripes ;))! I didn't actually believe the executive Lounge could sink any lower than the stay we had where the only food offering for afternoon tea was the left over breakfast stuff (at 3pm), but I think this stay rivaled that :shock:.

At least at afternoon tea, there was one cake and some biscuits that were fresh. However we arrived at about 3.05 and there was no milk in the coffee machine, no one on duty in the lounge and the used coffee capsule drawer was full as well, which meant our much anticipated coffee was just not happening. I would have thought prior to an anticipated influx of guests, such things would have been checked and fully prepared, but anyway, the lady was along in due course and we did end up with our coffees and cake. Hooray!

After a lovely walk along the esplanade and a "window" shop through the Sunday night market stalls, we ambled back to the room to prepare for 6pm canapes and drinks. We arrived at 6.20 to be advised by the only attendant that most of it was finished :shock:.....at 6.20! The hot food was not just finished, but gone and cleaned up, the tired old antipasta spread had no meat selection left at all, the breads looked like what was left after a herd of rats had finished, there were bread sticks but virtually no crackers and it appeared no cheeses had made it out at all, which left the only offering being pumpkin soup and a bowl of jelly beans! Now I've seen some bloody ordinary offerings here at HSP over their short history, but never had I seen such a ratty display of leftovers! The lounge was also partitioned off with storage of sorts happening in the eastern area which also meant the balcony was not accessible (there was no function) and although the lounge was not full, there were still a good 30 - 35 people there, so not empty either. There was a mix of disbelief, mild amusement and utter dispair amongst the guests and the high quality aura was assisted by the rugby being on at volume with no body watching it????

I asked to speak to the lounge manager. The lounge manager had the week-end off. What's that? Surely they have shift supervisors or something, but fortunately the sole male attendant (who was without doubt, well over his head) was joined by a very capable lady from Salt who quickly organised for a hotel duty manager to come up and address the situation. She was alarmed at what she found and proceded to organise more hot food to be brought up from Salt, more wine to be brought out (the few bottles were almost finished), the cheeses to be brought out, the meats to be restocked but despite this excellent recovery from two very talented ladies, one has to ask how could Hilton allow that to happen? Even with the sterling efforts of those two it remained comical to closing time with breads being brought out without a breadknife, forks running out, glasses running out, no crackers for the cheese, no serviettes and no ladels for the rushed out pasta dishes. I took a few photos below at 6.30, but remember we arrived to nothing at 6.20. It took me ten minutes to get over my disbelief and get my phone out. HSP continues to have the exec lounge with the nicest view and the worst food and service.

View attachment 18091
The meat dishes!

View attachment 18092
The breads (note the vast selection of cheeses....not)

View attachment 18093
The hot food selection (note there were three pieces of fruit on offer)

View attachment 18094
And for good measure.....a filthy plate!

Thanks for the entertaining read.. Regarding the losses report, I was conjuring up the comical 'Fawlty Towers" & Basil the waiter..
At certain times, this comical service execution is often replicated & shamefully so by HSP. :shock:
The other guests in the EL surely would have been appreciative of your initial constructive criticisms regarding the sparse offerings.
 
The other guests in the EL surely would have been appreciative of your initial constructive criticisms regarding the sparse offerings.

I had other guests thank me for raising it with management. One couple had just arrived following on from stays in both Hiltons Cairns and Brisbane, which they described as awesome! They were more amused at the offering (or lack thereof) and stated to me that after Cairns and Brisbane, they thought HSP would be superb! Welcome to reality I say!
 
It's hard to imagine that management would let it get so bad. Obviously a problem that starts with the highest level of management.
 
I wouldn't be tempted to give them any of my business.

We've booked another 4 stays (quite good value at $148/nite) just to cheaply retain diamond! We were going to MEL in a couple of weeks but Lisa has to now work, so we decided the savings on the airfares will more than pay for some nice dinners out where we don't have to subject ourselves to the mandatory stress tests in the exec lounge :lol:.

I kept expecting to see a pic of Basil Fawlty and the Waldorf salad.

Basil was no where in sight (perhaps fighting a fire in the kitchen), but Manuel was there! When we first looked, Lisa decided to try the best looking piece of scrap bread and put some antipasta with it. Trouble was, the bread was hard. She told Manuel and asked for fresh bread and his reply was "No Ma'am, it's soft and fluffy in the middle".......the middle?? Middle of what, it was a slice of bread, not a loaf and it looked like bread but felt like toast! She asked him to feel it, but he wouldn't and kept rolling his eyes. Perhaps Manuel wanted the left over bread for his pet Siberian Hamster!
 
I had other guests thank me for raising it with management. One couple had just arrived following on from stays in both Hiltons Cairns and Brisbane, which they described as awesome! They were more amused at the offering (or lack thereof) and stated to me that after Cairns and Brisbane, they thought HSP would be superb! Welcome to reality I say!

I totally agree that compared to HSP, Hilton Brisbane is an awesome hotel.
I stay there almost every week and never had any complains about the service, lounge, rooms or restaurant.

The only benefit of staying at HSP is their great location when going on holiday to Surfers Paradise.
 
I totally agree that compared to HSP, Hilton Brisbane is an awesome hotel.
I stay there almost every week and never had any complains about the service, lounge, rooms or restaurant.

The only benefit of staying at HSP is their great location when going on holiday to Surfers Paradise.

Perhaps the HSP staff & management could do with a workplace exchange for a month or two.. ;)
 
Basil was no where in sight (perhaps fighting a fire in the kitchen), but Manuel was there! When we first looked, Lisa decided to try the best looking piece of scrap bread and put some antipasta with it. Trouble was, the bread was hard. She told Manuel and asked for fresh bread and his reply was "No Ma'am, it's soft and fluffy in the middle".......the middle?? Middle of what, it was a slice of bread, not a loaf and it looked like bread but felt like toast! She asked him to feel it, but he wouldn't and kept rolling his eyes. Perhaps Manuel wanted the left over bread for his pet Siberian Hamster!

Oh dear God, how incompetent.

The want to grab the nearest spoon, wipe it across Manuel's face and then sharply strike him on the head with the spoon...... how did Mrs swanning_it not find that action appropriate for such an inappropriate response.

I mean, HSP is not the first property to sometimes have a bread selection where the bread was as hard as cardboard coupons. Mind you, some traditional French baguette is very, very crusty (people with dentures need not attempt to eat). But there is a difference between crusty and cardboard.

This attendant tops boomy's complaint of the non-5* chef.
 
I have three days at HSP in December. I'm starting to wonder whether I will regret this.
 
We've booked another 4 stays (quite good value at $148/nite) just to cheaply retain diamond! We were going to MEL in a couple of weeks but Lisa has to now work, so we decided the savings on the airfares will more than pay for some nice dinners out where we don't have to subject ourselves to the mandatory stress tests in the exec lounge :lol:.

What time of year are you going to get a rate like that? The best I can find in October (not holidays) is over double that :(
 
What time of year are you going to get a rate like that? The best I can find in October (not holidays) is over double that :(

HSP hotel $148 - King guest room with Gov't rate. AAA is $189 pretty much through to years end (holidays excluded).
 
I have three days at HSP in December. I'm starting to wonder whether I will regret this.

I have a few more before than, so I'll report back how they compare if you like.

I did notice on our weekend stay, an amenity kit I can't recall ever seeing before at an Aussie Hilton, which may be of interest to you beardoc...........a razor kit! ;)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Become an AFF member!

Join Australian Frequent Flyer (AFF) for free and unlock insider tips, exclusive deals, and global meetups with 65,000+ frequent flyers.

AFF members can also access our Frequent Flyer Training courses, and upgrade to Fast-track your way to expert traveller status and unlock even more exclusive discounts!

AFF forum abbreviations

Wondering about Y, J or any of the other abbreviations used on our forum?

Check out our guide to common AFF acronyms & abbreviations.
Back
Top