Well all Platinum members have received (or will) an email from Velocity this morning - the subject of which was one of many parst of the discussions we had with the focus group, as well as my recent one-on-one interaction. Wasn't our suggested outcome, so I'm disappointed, but can understand that VA is running a business.
The issue is that not all Platinum members fly Flex. Small businesses, or even SME's, try to save $ and Choice fares give enough flexibility - why pay the uplift for the chance to use the complimentary upgrade. I've only done that twice in the last 12 months, and am 1/2 on being able to access the upgrade. The cost differential on both fares was les than $80, so worth the opportunity.
I'm much less likely to spend double (or quadruple) the upgrade credits to access the upgrade seat if I'm buying Choice. I'll go back to looking at loads. But it is handy if you're nearing the end of your membership year and they're going to be lost.