There does seem to be a conflict between the WP Guest Access Rule and the OWE Guest Access Rule.
If I'm on CX for example and my guest is on QF then under OWE rules they should get admitted right? Or are we entering BA lounge-dalek territory with arbitrary rules that defy logic...
I understand that you are admitted under a single class of "eligibility" (for lack of a better description) which may depend on which FF program you are using to gain entry, that is if you are using a FF program to gain entry in the first place.
In your example this is my interpretation:
If you are using your QF WP status (whilst flying CX non-F) to gain entry, then QF rules are used (1 guest, must be travelling with you) - not OWE rules.
If you are flying CX F (hypothetically, I don't know if CX operates int F out of SYD or MEL) and using your F ticket to gain entry (regardless of FF program used), then int OW F rules are used: (Next onward flight that day must be on a
oneworld operated and marketed flight[SUP]#[/SUP].
One guest allowed. Must be travelling on a oneworld operated and marketed flight[SUP]
#)[/SUP]
This probably won't apply to your situation, but another example is:
If you are a non-QF OWE flying CX using your non-QF OWE status to gain entry, then OWE rules are used (Next onward flight that day must be on a
oneworld operated and marketed flight[SUP]#[/SUP].
One guest allowed. Must be travelling on a oneworld operated and marketed flight[SUP]
#)[/SUP]
I take it that OW rules are used for entry into the SYD/MEL F Lounges if the member is of a OW program that is
not QFF. (ie OW rules only apply to QFF members when they are gaining entry to a non QF OW lounge)
See serfty's post on page 1:
http://www.australianfrequentflyer....ram/first-lounge-guests-41429.html#post647958
However the rules for F pax (QF and non-QF OW) have changed since that was posted, there is a guest stipulation for QF F pax now:
One guest allowed and must be travelling with the member.
Eligibility and Access to The Qantas Club lounges
I guess one way to get around such rules is to join a non-QF OW FF program, get to OWE level and use that for entry!
Or, book a QF F metal codeshare flight with a non-QF OW flight number and use OW F rules..