Help me choose - J in SQ (longer transit) or MH (shorter transit)?

YOLO_Mum

Newbie
Joined
Apr 28, 2025
Posts
1
Long time member, but I forgot my login so had to setup a new one 😞

I looked at this on the weekend and decided I need help planning the flights for my ‘mums trip’ to the Maldives later this year, specifically flights from ADL-KUL-ADL as the KUL-MLE have already been booked. And, I want to treat myself to Business Class since there are no kids with me. I’m paying so want it to be a nice experience.

Options are
1 - Malaysia Airlines ADL-KUL Return - direct flight 11am-4pm on the way there, 1030pm-810am on the way back - $3,975 . Very simple, no connections other than to-from Male.
2 - Singapore Airlines - SYD-SIN-KUL - and then KUL-SIN-ADL or SIN-ADL with a seperate flight from KUL-SIN on the way back - $4,216. Longer transit time, and connections.

I have always wanted to try SQ J Class and have heard that MH food and IFE is no where near as good as SQ, and the QF points/SCs are nothing to write home about so the extra $250 to fly SQ seems to be worth it, but it would mean leaving ADL on the 6am flight (instead of 11am) and returning at 5pm (instead of 8:10am). Not a huge deal as it’s just me and my book (did I mention I’m not travelling with kids?!).

I am just a bit worried about a 2 hour connection time in KUL from the MLE flight landing at 7:40pm, and the SQ flight leaving at 9:45pm. Do you think there is any chance MH Male would check my bags through to the SQ flight so I don’t have to collect & recheck? Alternatively, I thought about booking a MH shuttle flight leaving at 11:30pm for $50 to get me to Singapore and then booking just the SQ SIN-ADL flight leaving at 8am the next morning - rather than chancing that I will make the 9:45pm SQ flight.

I also looked at going from Melbourne as DOM-INTL transfer is simpler, but strangely I can get an award flight from ADL-SYD for 12,000 points, but 24,000 and 36,000 to MEL. I think because it’s around the Melbourne Cup time.

I think these prices are fairly reasonable for business class, particularly as Adelaide doesn’t have too many international flights and small aircraft with less sale J seats.

Help me out - do I book with Malaysia Airlines or Singapore Airlines? If Singapore Airlines - do you think I would make a 2hr connection from MH to SQ in KUL or book the shuttle flight and just go SIN-ADL the next morning.
 
Having flown both MH and SQ J to/from ADL many times I will say that the SQ catering is far better than MH and probably all up a better product but even though the aircraft are older I tend to get more sleep onboard MH and do like their throne seats. I’m not a huge fan of the SQ seats for sleeping but for day flights I find them ok.
As for timings that’s entirely up to you but 2hrs at KUL is doable if everything goes smoothly but always good to have a backup
 
Elevate your business spending to first-class rewards! Sign up today with code AFF10 and process over $10,000 in business expenses within your first 30 days to unlock 10,000 Bonus PayRewards Points.
Join 30,000+ savvy business owners who:

✅ Pay suppliers who don’t accept Amex
✅ Max out credit card rewards—even on government payments
✅ Earn & transfer PayRewards Points to 10+ airline & hotel partners

Start earning today!
- Pay suppliers who don’t take Amex
- Max out credit card rewards—even on government payments
- Earn & Transfer PayRewards Points to 8+ top airline & hotel partners

AFF Supporters can remove this and all advertisements

Become an AFF member!

Join Australian Frequent Flyer (AFF) for free and unlock insider tips, exclusive deals, and global meetups with 65,000+ frequent flyers.

AFF members can also access our Frequent Flyer Training courses, and upgrade to Fast-track your way to expert traveller status and unlock even more exclusive discounts!

AFF forum abbreviations

Wondering about Y, J or any of the other abbreviations used on our forum?

Check out our guide to common AFF acronyms & abbreviations.
Back
Top