I actually think the QFF program is Ok when compared to other ones. Likewise, the call-centre frustration is almost omni-present with all major entities these days. (without digressing too much, I have recently had much experience helping my daughter with dealings with Social Security - or whatever they call themselves these days - with her claim for student allowance. I used to work for these people, and I am simply astounded at the lack of training or knowledge this HUGE government department has now - I suspect the call centre staff there get max about a months training!)
But back to QF, and trying to distill just three main issues I rate their highest in my personal experience. And curiously I think in advance these will all be somehow connected to QF's fame in inconsistency...
Number 1.- GET RID OF THE DEADWOOD in airborne staff. I know this is hard, due to industrial relations, etc. But it is my number one complaint about the QF experience. It has not happened once, not twice, but many many times that I, as a P1, sitting in 1A, get the dreaded "eyes roll" when mid-flight on a long haul I dare to ask for a bottle of water, whilst travelling in business. There is no known planet or universe where this sort of shiite is acceptable.... Can Qantas please acknowledge that they are in a service industry, competing with airlines where staff literally bend over backwards to be nice. Yet half of QF staff are glorious! Get it together, get rid of the jaded ones. Support and promote the staff that are amazing. It is not really hard to identify who is who here....
Number 2.- get rid of the ridiculous cash components of FF redemptions. They are a joke due to what other airlines offer. And revamp the metrics on Reward seats available on long-haul flights. I understand their need to protect revenue, but guarantee at least a couple of seats on every flight for premium seat redemption's. (Sorry, that morphed into two items)
Number 3.- Overhaul the entire status game. Provide clear and specific advantages / perks at each level. Find ways to introduce solid perks such as a guaranteed upgrade or two each year for higher levels. Make members of QFF understand and value the levels.