I went to Sketch back in 2009. I think it only had one star back then but has since been awarded a second (so I assume the food is even better now?). Pretentious? Absolutely. But that's what I enjoyed about it! Each to their own I guess. Not sure if you're familiar with Melbourne at all but I'm the sort of person who is happier to go somewhere like The Smith or Spice Temple than something more 'old school' such as Jacques Reymond. Or having been to New York last year I'd choose Per Se over Eleven Madison Park one hundred times out of one hundred, even though EMP was just rated significantly above it in the latest survey that came out this week. Not sure what the OP's preferences are, just offering my 2 cents.
Back in London in October myself (courtesy of the .br special) so keen to try some new places.
Not at all quarreling with your choices or preferences, Edge.
Would be interested in hearing more recommendations from you. Personal recommendations are worth much more than two cents, so do give us some more.
Yes, I am very familiar with Melbourne. I live in the CBD, so have favourites around the inner city area, and few of them would be "old school".
In NYC, Per Se is one of my favourites, there or anywhere in the world, in fact - and, while I've enjoyed Eleven Madison, I am constantly surprised to see how highly it rates in a variety of rankings.
So, you see: We do have overlap in our preferences. Just not Sketches.
(Must admit that my judgement of it was based on one visit only, probably about the same era that you were there.)
In London, I have recently made a booking for a visit later this month at the new restaurant that has just taken over the old Nahm premises, and is a project headed up by Elena Arzak and her father. Arzak, in San Sebastian, must be one of the nearest things to perfection in the restaurant world - in my opinion - but the London opening has had very mixed reviews. The only way to test it is to go see for yourself, so that's what we are doing.
Will try to remember to report back.