https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BNPTlT8HXjk
If you're driving that far while tired, you're doing it wrong.
You miss the point - I was not tired in any way shape or form with the wonder pills.
I was wide awake and enjoying the pleasant high-speed drives.
Regards,
Renato
No the study does not support what you wrote in your post and the discussion on the article explains why.
You have written of your experiences driving whilst using caffeine.
Others (myself included) would not advise or advocate doing this.
This does not mean that I wont spend money or that I'm putting others at risk. Quite the opposite in fact.
As I stated previously I will drive properly rested and take adequate breaks.
No - the Case Study supports exactly what I wrote.
The article tries to refute the evidence within the Case study with ridiculous suppositions.
For example, one conclusion that can be drawn the article's conclusions is that drinking lots and lots of water will reduce truck crashes - because the truckers will have to stop and go to the toilet more often. The article is spurious, in my opinion, while the Case Study has the data to back up it's claims.
The other point which you and many others have made about driving rested contains one implicit assumption that I think is not valid at all. Yes, one can get up in the morning and plan to drive in a rested fashion for four or five hours to the hotel that one has booked. So, what happens if at the two mark, one is suddenly very tired? Stop for a while, take off and find 15 minutes later that one is tired again - then what? Ring up the booked hotel and cancel the booking, while looking for a hotel where you are?
The certainty that you and everyone else is expressing with regards to knowing exactly how long they can drive before getting fatigued strikes me as not being real.
Regards,
Renato
i'd prefer to use modavigil. get the alertness without the stimulant affects.
Thanks Jeffrey,
I've never heard of it, but shall investigate it.
Regards,
Renato
i hope youre drinking plenty of water whilst you drive or youre liable to end up with kidney, bladder or liver troubles from this stimulant use!
Thanks for that.
Well, I don't do such driving often enough for it to be a factor, but regardless, Coke Zero and Diet Pepsi are my constant companions on such drives.
Regards,
Renato
This thread is incredibly scary. I've driven once while tired to the point of almost falling asleep and it is not an experience I will ever repeat. To suggest people drug themselves up to keep on going is incredibly irresponsible.
You drove yourself to the point of almost falling asleep.
That is what is dangerous to you and others - and you could have avoided it with the use of caffeine.
Who's irresponsible?
Regards,
Renato
I have been trying for a while to come up with a response and have to stay I'm speechless.
Drugged up or otherwise, if you are tired then you are tired and if tired to the degree being discussed then you are dangerous on the roads. There have been many studies with published results that link degree of fatigue with a percentage of intoxication and MOST people these days won't/don't drink & drive.
Agree - if you are tired don't drive.
But if you are wide awake and alert and caffeinated - the Case Study raised earlier shows that you are less likely to have a crash.
Regards,
Renato
Yikes! Bags I not sharing the road or a car with you Renato! Sorry but driving those distances and at high speeds for extended periods simply cannot be safe. Maybe talk to a highway cop or ambos who have to scrape people off bitumen after high speed crashes. You know those ads - 'speed kills' '& ' fatigue kills'. They are based on fact. MrMac & I drove to Sydney last month in one go - not our intention when we set off actually just the way it panned out. the Hume is a lovely safe road now; minimal traffic and we had plenty of breaks. In a big safe car - Benz 500 - which is very easy to drive & ate up the ks. However we were both buggered by the time we got there, despite rest stops and swapping driving. We were at our physical limit and no way could that have been reduced by popping a pill.
You were at your physical limit - when you did not have to be. That is what was unambiguously dangerous.
You claim that the pill wouldn't work, and elected to keep driving despite the fatigue. So, why did you not take a No-Doz to see if it possibly stopped you being fatigued and a danger on the road? it couldn't possibly have made you more tired than you were.
Regards,
Renato