Oops, I am very slack. Didn't get back to this at all in a timely manner.
Anyway some comments:
1. Silver Muse is indeed lovely - cabins. are spacious (I'm comparing a balcony cabin with the like on the mainstream lines - Celebrity, RC, Princess and even Cunard, especially Ponant where this. was almost twice the size. Separate shower plus bath and walk in robe plus couch and easy chair.
2. Having no 'main' restaurant was a real plus for us as MrLtL loathes the barns on other ships and we spend all meals in specialty restaurants. Also the large number of tables for 2 was great for us.
3, All inklusive is just that and makes things very easy
4. Staff were generally excellent - except for a couple of situations where the service recovery just didn't happen (the fact that bookings made online for restaurants just disappeared and no one seemed to be able to do anything - until one enterprising waiter at the Grill fixed it in 2 minutes!). People we were supposed to hear back from seemed to go MIA.
5. Entertainment was so so - the Silver Singers (or whatever they are) tried but didn't quite cut it, One evening had a classical pianist who was very good, and a couple of shows had the band backing them rather than pre recorded music which was much better. I don't care if it was the London Phil it was still taped!
6. Trivia seemed very popular though we are not joiners for things like that - but others seemed to be having fun.
7. Other daytime activities for sea days were a bit thin - a cooking demo but not much else.
8. Food overall was fantastic but they didn't do the gala nights well - Christmas Eve and Night - a lot of miscommunication about the need to book - the daily chronicle said one thing (only if a group over 4) and the word around was everyone had to book (which was correct!). That's pretty sloppy.
9. The space to passenger ratio is huge - this ship is 20% larger than Azamara for those who know them but has 100 pax less,
Overall we were very impressed.