Knowing Anna's background, I'm going to leave myself wide open here, but here goes
What is QF supposed to do in this situation? Fork out its own cash to buy replacement flights on other carriers for every single QFF member with a QFF reward booking on another carrier that has been stuffed up by that other carrier?
I know in part you are expressing and I'm quoting only one side of the equation
, but ...
Its not necessarily that the other carrier has 'stuffed up'. Just a cancellation, which we accept happens from time to time. QF should 'make good' the situation that they took payment for. They should explore all the options - getting a new seat released, making one of its own Award seats available, using an indirect route, releasing a revenue seat, going outside OneWorld (which has been done before). Yes, it may cost them money - else the customer pays either in lost opportunity or lost $$ for connections and bookings foregone if its cancelled. Multi-billion corporation Vs individuals. Who should pay?
But another part of me thinks travel generally is still clawing its way out of the pandemic mess, and why should QF be held responsible in this unstable environment to rebook pax where other airlines have changed flights that were scheduled perhaps many months prior? I don't see how QF can force another airline to make a reward seat available for a QFF member, and QF probably can't afford to stump up cash for replacement flights for every QFF member who finds their reward booking on another carrier has been rescheduled or cancelled.
First, Qantas is primarily responsible in these cases because 1) they have received payment and 2) they are the organiser. No matter if the flights are on their own metal or others - its been paid for to Qantas Who else is responsible? The customer? Has no standing with the other airline. The other airline? The customer isn't their customer. Airlines know better than us about the risk of cancellations. Presumably Qantas could see the problems in their own opertions coming (maybe they didn't
) so should have know it was a looming issue with others.
As for forcing a seat. I don't know the ins and outs of the oneWorld Agreement, but I'm guessing there must be something to cover this situation; but if there are simply no seats on the booked airline, again, Qantas should 'make good' some other way. Not just dump it back to the customer 'we'll refund the points' - leaving the costs etc of the rest of the itinerary, hotels etc on the customer's account.
As being able to afford to make good - well, you'd know better than me - that's a question of insolvency, isn't it? Now, we know that the airline would be able to fund replacements, it would just be chronically expensive. Maybe a hit to the bottom line would make them more cautious in their dealings. QFF is a huge profit centre for them - its not as if they are going to stop making award flights available.
when booking booking on partner airlines QF is nothing more than a TA and points are the currency. As I do not use TA's following comment may or may not be be correct, if a TA makes a booking and then the carrier changes/ cancels and impacts the travellers plan is it the TAs fault, is the TA expect to pay for another flight etc.
I don't think the analogy about Qantas being a glorified TA is accurate on a number of fronts.
I have no contract with my TA, other than one of good faith. They arrange services, they don't supply. I do not pay my TA - they receive commissions from the airlines (this may change with commissions being slashed).
With Qantas taking my points in exchange for an Award seat on their metal or others: I have a formal contract with them (ticket with 081- number) - no matter that its infinitely flexible in their favour, it is a formal relationship. Qantas receives payment from me for services to be delivered. Qantas has a formal relationship with other carriers if they are involved.
If the services the TA arranges for me cannot be provided, no, it isn't the TA's fault and they are not expected to pay. They are expected to use best endeavours to rectify (something Qantas isn't doing at the moment). But again, they are merely an agent - my 'contract' is with Qantas, directely via the ticket.