I must confess to struggling with the P1 thing. Recent trip SYD - LST. Heading to airport early, called the SST to ask for assistance on the smoothest trip home. My plan was lounge upgrade to J (using points, not asking for freebee) and an empty seat next to me on the MEL - LST Dash 8. Advice was to stick with my existing MEL flight as it had the most available J seats.
Because I had luggage, I checked again prior to dispatching my bag in SYD. Possibly a little bit paranoid but my original flight was the tightest connection to LST and I had several earlier flights to choose from. One delay and I'd be spending the night in Melbourne. All good, I was told several J seats available. Sent bag down chute, through security, into the lounge. Smooth run, five minutes max. Asked for upgrade and was told J was full. Boarding the plane, I couldn't help but notice at least two staff members in J. No big deal, I was in the economy seat I paid for. Hadn't expected 7F with 7E occupied, but it happens. I was however left wondering whether the SST team see empty seats in J, whilst the airport staff see seats with staff in them?
Come the next leg, I found myself in 5D (on a Dash 8) with an extremely large gentleman of Polynesian extraction next to me. He was really nice and did his best but it was still a cramped journey. He had come from Perth so his BP was issued well before mine. Had it been a full flight, I wouldn't have been annoyed but in the rows ahead of me, I counted five empty seats and there were more behind.
Perhaps all of those enjoying the company of their shadows were all P1 and I drew the short straw but I'm skeptical. I'm debating whether to pursue it further. Seems petty, but what's the point of being P1 if you can't get a decent seat? Realistically, all I ask of the status is a decent seat, although the Adelaide Hills tour sounded good!