Regional TR SYD-PQQ-SYD Aka E-Jet Vs Q400

Status
Not open for further replies.

yohy?!

Established Member
Joined
Nov 30, 2009
Posts
4,499
Qantas
Silver
Hello AFFers

Thought I should try to give a little back considering I have made some brilliant savings since seeking advice on this forum.

Today I took a trip to Port Macquarie for business. Thanks to my employer's best flight of the day policy I was booked onto the morning DJ E-170 flight to PQQ and back on the QFlink Q400 flight in the early evening.

Arriving at SYD (at an hour I'd sooner forget I was awake at) I passed by The Lounge wistfully on the way through security - will be sampling that also in a couple of weeks on my next DJ flight.

Boarding was quick and efficient, I was seated in seat 8D on VH-ZHA. Our 3 crew on this flight ranged from early 20s to mid 30s, a good mix I believe as I found them to be efficient and attentive.

The E-Jets seats are noticeably wider than DJs 737 ones however the pitch felt just as tight. Although this is an extremely short flight - 30 mins in the air the cabin service was good and I was grateful to receive a strong coffee to help wake me up.

I found the E-Jet cabin to have some strange high pitched whistling sounds I've not heard before in jet aircraft, nevertheless my flyers-anxiety was not playing up too badly because of it.

Our passage through the storm cells up the coast was relatively smooth with only some mild turbulence, I have to admit to being a little excited at the Captain reporting the possibility of a missed approach at PQQ due to the low cloud - I've read quite a few accounts of them as descrived as rollercoaster-like...fun!

We arrived on time to the minute into PQQ with a very soft landing comparable to others I've experienced in A320s...I've found DJs older 737s to be quite rough touching down.

-----------------

After an exhausting day dealing with a difficult client I was glad to be back at PQQ for the trip home.I was quite surprised that Qantaslink flights were not subject to security screening, I'm not sure I understand the logic of how prop planes are less likely to experience security incidents...perhaps someone knows the answer here?

Boarding through the 'pool fence' was thoroughly unglamourous, I certainly didn't expect it of a 'full service' airline. I have to admit to being a bit disappointed at the seat I was assigned following online checkin - 16C with a sequence number of 1! Again perhaps someone can enlighten me if this is normal on regional QF flights...

We had 2 crew on this flight, both who appeared to be products of QFs 'next generation' salary and benefit packages ie fancy suits and wrap dresses with minimal effort or interest.

I found the Q400 seat pitch to be quite nice and the seat comfortable enough for the short trip back to SYD. Having both the QF and QFlink inflight magazines on hand was a good touch too.

Following takeoff the seat belt stayed on for quite a long time following some mild turbulence, I found the cabin crew's giggling personal conversations via the crew intercom mildly amusing until we were told that due to the turbulence there would be no trolley service!

I'm all for safety and I understand the logic of not serving hot drinks in a possibly turbulent cabin environment but I'm also not a fool - I've been on DJ flights with cabin crew being flung on the floor that still managed to serve me a beer with a smile - not impressed!

I also found the Q400 WC to be slightly ridiculous, I wouldn't be surprised at larger pax having issues with using those facilities! I do realise this was a regional flight however I've been on NZ regional flights on smaller aircraft where the lav has been much more spacious.

After an uneventful landing with a very interesting (aand close up) fly past of the Kurnell refinery we were on the ground in SYD and stepping off onto the bus....good consistency QF, keeping in step with the unglamorous departure!


---------------------

In conclusion I'd have to say that I was very impressed with DJs E-jet product, it represented a 30% saving over the equivalent QF flight which kept my employer happy while delivery superior service, hardware and overall experience.
 
Nice TR. Sounds like the E-jet is a winner (was there no late departure on DJ home or were they just more $$$)??


On the "hard landing" in DJ 737s, it's a characteristic of the 737 (not exclusive to DJ) - they tend to be more "flown" onto the runway a bit more than the A320s / others. At least, that's according to one of QF's senior pilots who was explaining the landing characteristics of the 734 to me. May be partially related to the (relative to an A320) shorter landing gear.

Thanks for the TR - "regional" TRs are always great.
 
The Frequent Flyer Concierge team takes the hard work out of finding reward seat availability. Using their expert knowledge and specialised tools, they'll help you book a great trip that maximises the value for your points.

AFF Supporters can remove this and all advertisements

DJ did have a later departure on the E-Jet which was cheaper however I was eager to make my escape back to rather than hanging around another hour and a half :)

Thanks for the info on the 737 landings thats quite interesting.
 
Qantas normally has same security screening as Virgin where you go through the "new section" of the airport that screens cabin bags etc.
Prior to DJ servicing the area you just booked in checked luggage and traipsed out onto the QF plane with cabin bags when you were called.
Baggage reclaim is now much slower from both services & there are now parking charges for stays over 2hrs
DJ EJets certainly give the impression that you are coming in to land at a faster rate are are noisier overhead where we are (<5 minutes flying time from airport.)
 
Yeh I fully expected to go through security but it wasn't even open when the QF flight was due to go out - could have taken anything on board in my carry-on
 
Hello AFFers


Boarding through the 'pool fence' was thoroughly unglamourous, I certainly didn't expect it of a 'full service' airline. I have to admit to being a bit disappointed at the seat I was assigned following online checkin - 16C with a sequence number of 1! Again perhaps someone can enlighten me if this is normal on regional QF flights...

16C sounds like you have no status;:( my last trip on the Dash 8-400 I was able to select a heap of seats rows 8-16 but the non status FTer I was flying with could only get row 15 or 16. Check in at 24hours from Qantas is a load of cough; unless you have status.

I went through PQQ last year on a Dash 8-300 from SYD-PQQ what a bumpy flight that was; the lunch service started and then stopped due to the number of bumps.
 
Yeah I'm only NB...the OLCI stated that no seat selection was possible at all! I could only enter winod or aisle preferences.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Enhance your AFF viewing experience!!

From just $6 we'll remove all advertisements so that you can enjoy a cleaner and uninterupted viewing experience.

And you'll be supporting us so that we can continue to provide this valuable resource :)


Sample AFF with no advertisements? More..
Back
Top