simongr said:
In terms of general preferences I am trying to work out what to set as my preference. I have set "forward upper window" for int'l and "forward aisle" for domestic. What concerns me is that if I fly int'l on a non-747 it says "no preference will be registered" - do other people select simply forward window/aisle to guarantee (as much as you can guarantee anything flying) forward - or is experience that if you choose forward/upper/window(or aisle - I still cant decide on that) that if flying business class on a non-747 that you still get forward?
For international flights, I find the FF profile entry to be irrelevant for anyone with Sapphire or Emerald status flying with QF. Once the booking has been made (does not need to be ticketed), just phone QF on 131211 and ask to have a seat pre-allocated for you. Then just chose the best seat available to you at the time.
The computer system will auto-allocate you a seat when you make the reservation. But it makes not difference at all where that auto-allocated seat has been placed when its a 2 min phone call to discuss with a real person who can tell you what seats are available and you can choose any of the ones available no matter what your stated preference happens to be in your profile.
And for domestic flights, I think you are better to go to a real check-in agent and ask for an exit-row seat rather than taking pot luck with the auto-allocation system. You may be surprised how often the exit row seats are actually available. If you really want to use Quick Check, then use the system to check for different seats. Again you may be amazed how often the forward seats are available via QuickCheck due to last minute changes by elite FFs who had been auto-allocated their preference and changed to a different flight.
Personally I am much less concerned about the seat allocation for a 1-2 hour domestic flight than I am for a 14 hour international flight. I will always check the seat maps on-line (via ExpertFlyer) for international flights, select the one I want and call QF on 131211 and ask to be moved to that specific seat. The computer system is not smart enough to know my seating preference for each aircraft type and route. I may chose a different seat based on being a day or night flight, east-bound vs west-bound, over water or land etc.
So my QF FF profile just has a generic "forward aisle" includes, and I always call to select the seat I want. And it makes no difference if I use my QF Plat number or my AA Plat number in the booking for international flights since I always phone and select the seat I want regardless of what the system has auto-allocated me.