SYD to MEL 737 or A330 in J?

Status
Not open for further replies.

CaptainCurtis

Established Member
Joined
Oct 8, 2013
Posts
1,248
I haven't flown domestically in quite some time (although I guess most of us haven't 😅). I see Qantas are running both the 737 and A330 - is one generally recommended over the other in J, or should I try them both?
 
Solution
It's a hour flight so it's really not that big a deal, but the 330 is definitely a preferred product for any flight.

ALso note during late Dec and into Jan there is a 787 on rotation... which has the same product as the 330 in J.
Last minute aircraft swap from B737 to A330 a few days out from my flight so I've now lost my seat 4A...
 
Ahh OK, confused I was. The thread title is SYD to MEL 737 or A330 in J?
Oh I missed that... Just as confusing as the flight info itself:

My flight (swapped to A330)
1646118240330.png

Another flight (already scheduled as A330)
1646118444744.png
 
Last edited:
Seems to be a lot of chopping and changing. The travel agency we use had 330 operating 5.30pm flights on the route but then EF and when booked it's only 737 😑 so changed to 5pm.

I've also noticed seat blocking operating unusually within the T-80 period.
 
I've also noticed seat blocking operating unusually within the T-80 period.
Initially I couldn't select rows 23 to 28 (as they have been lifted and shifted from the corresponding rows on the B737?)
Updated - Some seats have since opened up so I managed to select row 23...
 
Last edited:
Seems to be a lot of chopping and changing. The travel agency we use had 330 operating 5.30pm flights on the route but then EF and when booked it's only 737 😑 so changed to 5pm.

I noticed this on the Qantas website also last week. The little aircraft icon said A330, but clicking into the flight details or viewing on EF showed 737.

Last minute aircraft swap from B737 to A330 a few days out from my flight so I've now lost my seat 4A...

Sounds like a good opportunity for a classic upgrade reward?
 
Our Mel-Cns has quietly subbed a 738 into what was a 330. Yet the seats rolled over. Lucky I looked. 28B not such a great seat on the 738…..
 
Sounds like a good opportunity for a classic upgrade reward?
Rather not risk this:
 
Some of us on here do have a "love spot" for any of the wide bodies (planes), that QF and VA (yes, VA used to) fly.
Seeing that you lost 4A on the 737, they might offer you an op up, who knows, or they might change the plane back to a 737.
Guess the only way is to wait till OLCI opens, and see what they offer you.
(((Mr/Ms xx_, you have now got seat 1A))), imagine if that happened!
We can always dream.
Edit:
Our Mel-Cns has quietly subbed a 738 into what was a 330. Yet the seats rolled over. Lucky I looked. 28B not such a great seat on the 738…..
If you get a lot of kids in that/those rows, they might close that zone off to non parents or single men (I know, quasi discrimination, but still), and move you a bit forward.
I prefer the back of the plane, if not in J, as most of the time, they have back door embarkation and disembarkation too, so you could get on and off faster than the middle of the plane.
 
Last edited:
Our Mel-Cns has quietly subbed a 738 into what was a 330. Yet the seats rolled over. Lucky I looked. 28B not such a great seat on the 738…..
If you get a lot of kids in that/those rows, they might close that zone off to non parents or single men (I know, quasi discrimination, but still), and move you a bit forward.
I prefer the back of the plane, if not in J, as most of the time, they have back door embarkation and disembarkation too, so you could get on and off faster than the middle of the plane.
 
Over xmas there were 330 flying between SYD and CNS, I was wanting to book the same for this year, but every single flight shows 737 (not worth upgrading to J on a 737 imo) - where are the 330s being used? Surely 330s are better on longer flights than the quick SYD-MEL.
 
If you get a lot of kids in that/those rows, they might close that zone off to non parents or single men (I know, quasi discrimination, but still), and move you a bit forward.
I prefer the back of the plane, if not in J, as most of the time, they have back door embarkation and disembarkation too, so you could get on and off faster than the middle of the plane.
I’m travelling with the family - have re-selected forward seating. 👍
 
Over xmas there were 330 flying between SYD and CNS, I was wanting to book the same for this year, but every single flight shows 737 (not worth upgrading to J on a 737 imo) - where are the 330s being used? Surely 330s are better on longer flights than the quick SYD-MEL.

In the case of SYD-CNS, it's most likely just due to demand. Demand will be higher in school holidays and the winter, and somewhat lower in the wet season outside of holidays.

Yes, widebodies (if they can sell the full capacity), are often better on longer flights due to their fuel capacity and efficiency - the passenger-mile cost for an A330 will be very efficient on a longer segment like PER-SYD or MEL-CNS. If used on a short SYD-MEL flight, the costs per mile will be slightly higher due to extra takeoff/climb fuel used for the larger plane. But the reason the A330 (and before it the 767) is useful for SYD-MEL is the higher capacity per landing slot. Airports' capacity is limited mostly by number of takeoffs and landings, with the size difference of an 737 vs A330 not a major factor (although does have a small effect). So that's why you'll see larger planes being used on busy routes like SYD-MEL during peak hours - more passengers can be carried during a period when it might not be possible to add more flights.

There are other secondary reasons, such as rotating the planes to a maintenance base, which causes occasional flights to have an A330 where you might not otherwise expect. Airlines also plan their fleet utilisation carefully - a large, expensive plane like an A330 is best used as continuously as possible, so if there are gaps in the schedule where it could be used, they will try to use it. For example, many Perth to east coast flights run at night with A330's, and these same aircraft can be used for MEL-SYD shuttles in the daytime.
 
n the case of SYD-CNS, it's most likely just due to demand. Demand will be higher in school holidays and the winter, and somewhat lower in the wet season outside of holidays.

That is why i thought they'd have at least one of the flights on the 330 over Christmas this as they did in 2021. Typically between xmas and new years there is very little business travel between SYD and MEL but a heap of holiday travel going north. I will just keep an eye out to see if they swap out aircraft.
 
In the case of SYD-CNS, it's most likely just due to demand. Demand will be higher in school holidays and the winter, and somewhat lower in the wet season outside of holidays.

Yes, widebodies (if they can sell the full capacity), are often better on longer flights due to their fuel capacity and efficiency - the passenger-mile cost for an A330 will be very efficient on a longer segment like PER-SYD or MEL-CNS. If used on a short SYD-MEL flight, the costs per mile will be slightly higher due to extra takeoff/climb fuel used for the larger plane. But the reason the A330 (and before it the 767) is useful for SYD-MEL is the higher capacity per landing slot. Airports' capacity is limited mostly by number of takeoffs and landings, with the size difference of an 737 vs A330 not a major factor (although does have a small effect). So that's why you'll see larger planes being used on busy routes like SYD-MEL during peak hours - more passengers can be carried during a period when it might not be possible to add more flights.

There are other secondary reasons, such as rotating the planes to a maintenance base, which causes occasional flights to have an A330 where you might not otherwise expect. Airlines also plan their fleet utilisation carefully - a large, expensive plane like an A330 is best used as continuously as possible, so if there are gaps in the schedule where it could be used, they will try to use it. For example, many Perth to east coast flights run at night with A330's, and these same aircraft can be used for MEL-SYD shuttles in the daytime.

Another reason for the A330s on SYD-MEL and to a lesser extent SYD-BNE is their capacity to carry a lot more freight compared to the 737's which is critical in the current environment.
 
Read our AFF credit card guides and start earning more points now.

AFF Supporters can remove this and all advertisements

Status
Not open for further replies.

Become an AFF member!

Join Australian Frequent Flyer (AFF) for free and unlock insider tips, exclusive deals, and global meetups with 65,000+ frequent flyers.

AFF members can also access our Frequent Flyer Training courses, and upgrade to Fast-track your way to expert traveller status and unlock even more exclusive discounts!

AFF forum abbreviations

Wondering about Y, J or any of the other abbreviations used on our forum?

Check out our guide to common AFF acronyms & abbreviations.
Back
Top