The revocation of a Lifetime AApass

Hvr

Enthusiast
Joined
Jun 27, 2007
Posts
10,709
Qantas
LT Gold
My dad was one of the only people with a good-for-life, go-anywhere American Airlines pass. This is the true story of having – and losing – a superpower


A fascinating story of how a man used his AApass to travel the world on a whim and then its revocation by American Airlines written by his daughter.

She shares the high and low points of how it changed their life and the sad outcome for her father when it was revoked.

1569034616633.png
 
Saw that pop up on my google feed yesterday, but sure I'd read almost the identical article some time ago.

Definitely think the passholder was abusing it in the end, though AA could have handled it better
 
I feel revocation without compensation is a bit harsh on him. I mean letting it get to 3,000 plus no shows .... really they could have said something earlier.

And calling the reservations agents for therapy .... :oops:

But that article, what a load of drivel.
 
What a deal he was on given the large AA network. Had not seen this story before.

Sounds like he rorted the system from reading it, but global travel first class for $US250,000 was a great deal in the first place. :D



Man had his $250,000 lifetime first-class ticket cancelled after he cost the airline $21,000,000​

American Airlines' unlimited free pass for first-class tickets wound up costing them big time over the decades​

Dylan Murray

A frequent-flyer had his lifetime offer of free first class flights revoked after he ended up costing the airlines millions of dollars.

For many, a lifetime free pass for anything is a life-changing deal, and air travel is no exception. However, as American Airlines found out, a lifetime free pass doesn’t just sound too good to be true — it really is too good to be true.

In an attempt to make quick cash in 1981, American Airlines offered up free first-class tickets for life to any individual willing to pay them $250,000 on the spot.

At the time, this was done by the airline with the intention of making additional profits as they were dealing with financial struggles and were looking for a way out.


American Airlines initally offered the AAirpass for $250,000. (pexels/Alfred GF)

At face value, their plan worked. A total of 66 people purchased the lifetime pass, known officially as the AAirpass.


However, when you look deeper, this was one of the worst financial mistakes they ever could’ve made, and it's all because of one man named Steven Rothstein.

Rothstein purchased the AAirpass in 1987, and within 21 years, he alone cost American Airlines over $21 million dollars in profits.

How did he do this? Well, even beyond the amenities and add-ons that come with riding first-class, it was the sheer amount of flying Rothstein did that cost the airline millions.

By 2008, Rothstein had traveled 30 million miles across 10,000 flights with American Airlines, all of which were free of charge.

If you do the math, you can see that just one passenger made the entire AAirpass program unprofitable.

Despite this, it took decades for American Airlines to come to the realization that Rothstein was costing them millions of dollars.

Once they had finally figured it out in 2008, they quickly cut off Rothstein in the middle of a travel day, leaving the man unable to board his flight to Bosnia as a result.

Rothstein flew across the world roughly 10,000 times before being stopped (Caroline Rothstein)

Rothstein flew across the world roughly 10,000 times before being stopped (Caroline Rothstein)

American Airlines also sued Rothstein as a result of his actions, though not for his personal overuse of the AAirpass.


Instead, they sued the stockbroker for fraud, accusing him of booking seats for non-existent passengers under names such as 'Bag Rothstein' and 'Steven Rothstein Jr', and also booking tickets for flights he was never planning to board.

Rothstein also admitted to offering up his ticket to those in need on numerous occasions throughout the 20+ years he had unlimited flights.

Speaking to Forbes back in 2019, Rothstein explained his side of the story, saying: “I gave a man in Seattle a ticket to go to his father’s funeral. I gave many people tickets to visit ill family members.

“I don’t view that as philanthropy, I view that as good deeds.”

Despite American Airlines' initial legal action, they and Rothstein eventually settled outside of court.

And, in case you were wondering, Rothstein now prefers to fly with United Airlines whenever he travels.

 
From a financial sense, anything “lifetime” without further identifiable contribution seems a bad idea.

QF are saddled with people like me who bought a lifetime QC pass nearly 30years ago. There is no requirement for me to contribute anything except hold a valid boarding pass for the day of travel. I and any travel associate have had countless Bourbon & Cokes while traveling on for example but not always BFOD on JQ or a CR flight on a partner airline.

QF lifetime gold is another that to me financially doesn't make sense. How many people on here work their way to lifetime gold and then switch allegiances and spend their money on another airline and only travel QF (or partner airline) for rewards flights.
 
That story is old. Only 66 such passes were sold. AA investigated the pass holders in 2007 and 2 of them including the fellow in this thread were found to be costing AA $US1 million a year. The 2 of them had their passes cancelled.

In 2007, during a period of financial instability for the airline, American Airlines assigned a "revenue integrity unit" to investigate AAirpass holders. The airline's investigators concluded that two AAirpass holders, Steven Rothstein and Jacques Vroom, were costing the airline more than $1 million annually. The airline points to accumulation of air miles for flights which they received for free under the AAirpass, allowing some passengers to accumulate tens of millions of miles as well as taxes and airport fees paid for by the airline.<a href="AAirpass - Wikipedia"><span>[</span>7<span>]</span></a> The program has been called "a huge disaster" for the company.<a href="AAirpass - Wikipedia"><span>[</span>10<span>]</span></a> The two AAirpass holders including their companion passes were terminated from the program when the airline accused them of fraudulent activity.

So why after 17years is this story still relevant. In the words of a Queen Latifah song - They had it coming.
 
That story is old. Only 66 such passes were sold. AA investigated the pass holders in 2007 and 2 of them including the fellow in this thread were found to be costing AA $US1 million a year. The 2 of them had their passes cancelled.



So why after 17years is this story still relevant. In the words of a Queen Latifah song - They had it coming.
Also Unilad is a site that commonly posts viral but very old stories on Social Media to drive traffic.
 
Read our AFF credit card guides and start earning more points now.

AFF Supporters can remove this and all advertisements

The "cost" to AA is overblown

The real losses are:
Flights he (or his aliases) would have paid for anyway (and as a savvy flyer many would be redemptions and upgrades) and that is assuming he would have always flown AA
Flights that were otherwise full in F
The food and drink he consumed
The jetfuel for him and his baggage

(Having said that, it's a similar fallacy to believing you are getting 10c/pt value flying an F redemption if you would only pay for a Y fare with your own cash)
 
Last edited:

Become an AFF member!

Join Australian Frequent Flyer (AFF) for free and unlock insider tips, exclusive deals, and global meetups with 65,000+ frequent flyers.

AFF members can also access our Frequent Flyer Training courses, and upgrade to Fast-track your way to expert traveller status and unlock even more exclusive discounts!

AFF forum abbreviations

Wondering about Y, J or any of the other abbreviations used on our forum?

Check out our guide to common AFF acronyms & abbreviations.
Back
Top