As a certified "not JQ's biggest fan" I believe I'm perfectly placed to answer the question.
The answer is simple -
IF the timing and price and conditions suit you, and you are flying JQ by CHOICE - then JQ is a good choice. Period - that's what it comes down to.
If you are a family of 5 wanting to fly MEL-OOL - then JQ is probably a great option (and maybe the only way you could afford such a vacation).
And if you live in the Golden Triangle where you have so many options that you genuinely have a choice between carriers/price/schedule then that's great.
And I 100% believe the positive experiences of those that have chosen to fly JQ and have had no problems with JQ.
BUT....
That is not the experience of everyone.
- If you have a problem - the experience of many is that JQ customer service is cough - simple as that (not guaranteed to be cough - but often is).
- If you are in a port that has been Jetstarised - you have no choice. I promise you - I didn't CHOOSE to have to pay $369 for a flight on JQ with no inclusions (would have happily paid that price if it was QF - but QF handed the route to JQ).
- A 1 hour bus-ride MEL-SYD is a totally different experience to longer flights where comfort/baggage/IFE/service are bigger factors.
- Some of us are sick and tired of QF screwing us over by forcing us to fly JQ with zero incentive to do so.
- There is a reason for the "I Blame JQ" mentality (eg the rants to JQ Customer Service on the FB page). Just because an individual post might be considered "ridiculous" to us informed regular flyers, doesn't mean the poster is a moron (they maybe a JQ-flying, bintang-drinking, wifebeater-wearing, thong-displaying, tramp-stamped bogan; but this is not my point).
There have been many incidents of LCC-Behaviour by JQ and not all are NoNews beatups - despite what we here at AFF might think of it.
It is an axiomatic fact that many punters view JQ negatively - such a brand perception is always rooted in fact.
Does that mean that you will have a negative experience - NO IT DOESN'T.
Does your lack of negative experience mean that someone else's is wrong, or that they are wrong to complain - NO IT DOESN'T.
So enough with the fanbois behaviour - enough with attacking
JohnK for his personal choices to dislike JQ. And on the flipside - if you have a rant/bad experience, fair enough but provide the details so others can avoid the same trap.
If you're making in informed personal choice to fly JQ because it suits your circumstances - great. But respect others who choose not to, or who fly JQ for reasons other than choice.
PS - JQ is great for $9 Price Beat JQ35 fares