I'll do whatever it takes to avoid Emirates Economy on the 773.

Status
Not open for further replies.

dzinh

Active Member
Joined
May 19, 2009
Posts
535
more pics on my blog

I've never intended to fly with Emirates until I needed to head over to Singapore to which Emirates had the perfect timing as well as fit perfectly into my budget which saw me book the flight ten hours before my flight.


I'm not usually one to leave flight booking up to a few hours before the flight but being spontaneous and living to you only live once meant I was paying quite a steep price for the flight which happened to fall into holiday season in Australia, but then again prices are always high when booking from Australia. With the flight departing Melbourne at 1900 meant that I could squeeze in a day of work before heading to the airport at 1630 which was perfectly timed just before peak hour on the freeway.

I walked through the doors of terminal two and headed for the departures hall which I made my way passed the Emirate check in which was crowded with passengers checking in bag. The great thing was I could bypass the lines with my hand bag and printed boarding pass which had the option of allowing me to head straight to the gate. I was stripped of status, lounge access and everything elite as I didn't hold status with Emirates or Qantas which didn't bother me too much as it was a one off flight.

image2.jpg

The girl taking me to Singapore.

While waiting in the gate lounge my name was called over the p.a system which saw me at the gate as the agent needed to scan my passport to which she issued me a new boarding pass on Emirates stock. Boarding began to commence so she invited me to board along with the parents and children which was nice of her as the passengers made their way downstairs from the departure hall.

I was greeted by two bubbly flight attendants and was directed to turn right as I made my way down the colourful cabin towards row 35 Charlie.

image8.jpg

My seat.

On the seat was a pillow, blanket and a pair of headphone to which I placed in the seat pocket before taking the opportunity to snap some pictures of the cabin.


Between seats and located just under the entertainment screen was a powerpoint which has become a thing of today and a necessity for all. The ICE system had a larger than normal and sharp screen which had a wide selection of movies, films, music and games which helped bypass time, it was unresponsive at time which I turned to the remote for ease when selecting and scrolling through items.


image18a.jpg

"Our economy class comes without compromise" - Taken from the Emirates website. The only thing that was compromised was space.

My flight to Singapore was a full and sold out flight meaning everyseat had a bum alocated to it. The Emirates economy class layout is a 3-4-3 which is ten across meaning a tight and narrow squeeze compared to other airlines who operate the same aircraft. It may not seem bad at all to the normal traveller but comfort factor breaks when you're sitting with your shoulders against your seat partner especially when it's a sold out flight. I was lucky enough to be travellng with a friend so we managed to maneuver into a few positions to try and find a comfortable spot which seemed to make the seven hour flight seem like a ten hour one.

The Boeing 777 is my favourite aircraft, not so with ten across in economy.

image22.jpg


I could just embrace and accept the limited space for a seven hour flight to Singapore and couldn't be happier when the prepare cabin for descent announcement was made. The seat itself was comfy when in the upright position and I had a few inches of legroom from my knees to the seat infront. When the seat reclined it was a different story as the seat reclined and slides forward meaning my knees were touching the seat infront which makes it hard to rest and stretch your legs properly.


image9.jpg

A storm was brewing behind those clouds.

As the final door was shut and the time was just over 1900 there was an announcement that there would be a ten minute delay as airport operations were still loading cargo which was fine. Another announcement thirty minutes later informed us that due to severe stormy weather all airport operations were on hold until the storm passed which lasted until 20:10.


image5e.jpg

In the time that we were waiting for the storm to pass flight crew handed out hot face towels, immigration forms for Singapore, food menu and did a pre departure water service.


It was 20:15 when airport operations recommenced loading the final pieces of cargo that saw us pushing back at 20:30, only an hour and half later than we were suppose to with an announcement from the captain that they would try their best to make up lost time. The flight crew was introduced and Emirates pride themselves for having multicultural crew with a total of 13 staff speaking different languages on the flight.

With a slight right turn onto the runway the worlds most powerful GE90 engines on any commercial aircraft let out an ear pleasing roar as we gained speed and gently glided into the air for Singapore. With a few turns here and there the aircraft continued to climb to a higher altitude as land began getting smaller. The seatbelt sign was eliminated a few seconds later before crew prepared the cabin for a dinner service.

image11w.jpg


Savoury biscuits and a drink run was performed while dinner was still heating up in the galley to which the announcement for crew to cease work and return to their seats as we would be facing turbulence. The plane shook and rattled as the captain managed to climb to a higher altitude and avoid the turbulence to which the crew recommenced their work ten minutes after.


image1w4.jpg

Chicken tagine with cous cous and grilled vegetables.

Beef or chicken? I decided on the chicken for dinner which was served with a Arabic mezze, pita bread and accompanied by a carrot cake. The meal was piping hot and had enough taste which went well with the pita bread, it was a meal eaten to stabilize the stomache and wasn't something that had a wow factor about it. The vegetables were fresh and crisp which is always a delight over the sometimes soggy and bland vegetables I've come across on some airlines. The meal also had a romeso spread with crackers which didn't appeal to me, it was like eating capsicum on crackers. The carrot cake was nice although after tasting a bite I could taste a weeks worth of sugar in that tiny slice.

Metal cutlery was also featured which is a nice touch and much better than any plastic fork especially when its a flimsy plastic fork. Giving Singapore airlines a run for their money which is always nice especially in economy.

Trays were swiftly cleared thirty minutes after the crew began the meal service and a check on the inflight map showed that we were only flying past Alice Springs which meant there was 5 hours of the flight left.


image2w1.jpg


Cabin lights were dimmed and the mood lighting was switched on to ease and create a relaxing mood in the cabin. The Boeing stars began to twinkle above as the moodloghting was phased out which reulted in a semi dark cabin. I managed to squeeze in a hours nap before waking up to which crew were doung a snack service of warm pies in the dark.

image222.jpg


The crew on the flight had smiles all round and were extremely young in their late twentys with the conversation that I had in the galley. They say a crew can make or break a flight and in this instance they were able to balance out between the comfort face of the flight.

We began descent into Changi airport one hour behind out estimated arrival hour which saw the plane glide down gently as we taxied towards the terminal. Passengers who were connecting onto Dubai were in luck as the gate for that second leg was the gate next to our plane which was in final boarding stages.

To be honest I probably wouldn't fly Emirates economy again unless I didn't have a choice due to comfort factor being a huge priority for me, especially with several other airlines who offer a more spacious economy cabin but besides that a very nice flight which I would rate just below Singapore airlines.
 
Thanks. re-inforced my views on Emirates Y. probably the biggest gulf between Y and premium cabin of any airline I'm aware of.
 
Thanks. re-inforced my views on Emirates Y. probably the biggest gulf between Y and premium cabin of any airline I'm aware of.

Probably something most Middle-East carriers have in common, not only Emirates.
 
Ive done EK Y on the 777 and never again. Especially with a larger pax beside me, it was not pleasant. Food was great though, for airline food.
 
Thanks for posting.

Note to self - EK Y 777 - NO!
 
Yes definitely avoid the 777 in Y. Economy on the A380 or A330 though is fine. Lets hope they never take up the 11 abreast a380 configuration which airbus has offered.

Its not just Emirates 777 you need to avoid, Etihad and Air New Zealand as well. Qatar is ok.
 
NZ have the same 3-4-3 Y layout on their refurbed 772 and 773! It can be very challenging.... challenging enough never to fly Y with them again! :)

Ooh Roo

Willie
 
Good trip report and interesting read.

Call me old fashioned but if you fly economy you know it's not a premium experience and therefore should always expect it to be ****house...
 
Great trip report, based on my experience is pretty accurate, although crew can make or break it. Despite the 3-4-3 the timing is great for getting back to SIN (for those of us who live here) or as you point out saving a day off (if living in MEL) so it's either EK or SQ (and usually SQ costs more). I actually don't find it too much note cramped than a 330 but the 3-3-3 777 (or even 2-5-2) is much better.

Oh one minor point. .... No luck involved in people making their connections to DXB, it's the same plane! The position of the entrance to the gate makes it look as if it's the next gate along, but it is the same gate. (Unless you were talking about the connection to CMB).
 
Ive done EK Y on the 777 and never again. Especially with a larger pax beside me, it was not pleasant. Food was great though, for airline food.

At least I can say I've done it :cool: but I mean if the flight load wasn't 100% and if there was an empty seat besides then it would of made a huge difference.

The dinner was okay, for all the airlines I've been on and they asian influenced food they serve compared to the food EK serve is quite a big difference.

Thanks for posting.

Note to self - EK Y 777 - NO!

AVOID unless you really have no other choices.

Good trip report and interesting read.

Call me old fashioned but if you fly economy you know it's not a premium experience and therefore should always expect it to be ****house...

I don't mind flying in economy here and there and don't have big expectations of economy, although some airlines have a much better experience than others. SQ's economy is less cramped as they only have 9 across on the 772/3 and I wouldn't hesitate booking a future trip with them. I would try to avoid EK, EY, NZ or whatever other airlines that do 10 across in Y. :)


Oh one minor point. .... No luck involved in people making their connections to DXB, it's the same plane! The position of the entrance to the gate makes it look as if it's the next gate along, but it is the same gate. (Unless you were talking about the connection to CMB).

It usually would be the same plane but as we got in an hour behind schedule I saw they were boarding another 773 right besides the gate :)

I only booked with EK because I really didn't have any other choice and with an ETA around 1900 it was the only way I could work at my new job without having to ask for a day off. Timing wise is a gem because you don't lose a day and get into SIN just before midnight which is a big plus. I saw towards the back end that the seating had changed into 2-4-2 but who really wants to sit that far back. :)
 
It usually would be the same plane but as we got in an hour behind schedule I saw they were boarding another 773 right besides the gate

My bad. Yes that would of course have been the other flight to DXB ( it goes via CMB), they must have held it for the connecting pax.

The SQ flight leaving half an hour later (19:30) is a good alternative to this flight if you can find reasonable fares.
 
Last edited:
My bad. Yes that would of course have been the other flight to DXB ( it goes via CMB), they must have held it for the connecting pax.

The SQ flight leaving half an hour later (19:30) is a good alternative to this flight if you can find reasonable fares.

I had my eye on that SQ flight as well but they wanted $1011 one way into SIN.. which was crossed off the list :( I wanted the 330 as it has couples seats which I love but it wasn't meant to be lol.
 
I think EY would have the biggest gap between Y and J of any airline. Never heard a good word about their Y.
EK J 777 is angled flat 2-3-2. Amazed they still have this- aren't 777s more than 50% of their aircraft?
 
We flew Y DBX to Venice return. Seemed like any other Y to me?
 
We flew Y DBX to Venice return. Seemed like any other Y to me?

I don't notice it too much if I do an EK return SIN-MEL, for example. I have done SQ one way and EK the other , both on 77Ws a few days apart, that's when you really notice the extra seat across.
 
Nice trip report.

Doesn't sound like the Emirates 777 is for me either.

Call me old fashioned but if you fly economy you know it's not a premium experience and therefore should always expect it to be ****house...
I'd expect that on LCCs.
 
Turn business expenses into Business Class! Process $10,000 through pay.com.au to score 20,000 bonus PayRewards Points and join 30k+ savvy business owners enjoying these benefits:

- Pay suppliers who don’t take Amex
- Max out credit card rewards—even on government payments
- Earn & Transfer PayRewards Points to 8+ top airline & hotel partners

AFF Supporters can remove this and all advertisements

EK J 777 is angled flat 2-3-2. Amazed they still have this- aren't 777s more than 50% of their aircraft?

Anyone got any views on the EK 777 J cabin 2-3-2 config.
Looking to get to BKK and it seems to be a well timed option again for a days work in Oz then jumping the flight.
I always take the QF A330 but am now wondering if the EK J product up is ok or not.
 
Anyone got any views on the EK 777 J cabin 2-3-2 config.
Looking to get to BKK and it seems to be a well timed option again for a days work in Oz then jumping the flight.
I always take the QF A330 but am now wondering if the EK J product up is ok or not.

We were on the Syd -BKK route in J a couple of weeks ago. Service was not up to scratch but maybe it was just that crew. We felt we paid for space not service. (But F on the way back as a free upgrade and were very pleased with the service. And space. :p)
 
Anyone got any views on the EK 777 J cabin 2-3-2 config.
Looking to get to BKK and it seems to be a well timed option again for a days work in Oz then jumping the flight.
I always take the QF A330 but am now wondering if the EK J product up is ok or not.

I would say the seats are very comfortable for a 7-8 hours flight. The only problem I find is that some early version of the seat have the small handset encased in a panel which is at shoulder level and can be VERY annoying for tall people when in a slightly reclined position. I have only had this seat version on the 3AM departure to KUL, never on the 6PM departure to SIN, but I may have been lucky.
 
Good trip report and interesting read.

Call me old fashioned but if you fly economy you know it's not a premium experience and therefore should always expect it to be ****house...

This x a million IMO :D
Have just completed a return trip in EK A380 Y SYD-AKL. Both Shrek and I agreed it was just tolerable for a short flight but no way either of us would travel medium or long haul sitting 10 across.
Personally I'd rather stay home.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Become an AFF member!

Join Australian Frequent Flyer (AFF) for free and unlock insider tips, exclusive deals, and global meetups with 65,000+ frequent flyers.

AFF members can also access our Frequent Flyer Training courses, and upgrade to Fast-track your way to expert traveller status and unlock even more exclusive discounts!

AFF forum abbreviations

Wondering about Y, J or any of the other abbreviations used on our forum?

Check out our guide to common AFF acronyms & abbreviations.
Back
Top