- Joined
- Apr 5, 2012
- Posts
- 266
- Qantas
- LT Silver
...desperate people seek desperate measures.
hey! I resemble that remark!
...desperate people seek desperate measures.
That is rubbish as far as the topic of this thread goes....
But I think it is quite clear that desperate people seek desperate measures.
By paying a bill that doesn't exist? It's not rubbish and I don't agree that it's common sense.That is rubbish as far as the topic of this thread goes.
It's not desperate at all, it is simply common sense.
If there is an opportunity to garner points outside of flying in a cost effective manner (e.g. points for spend plus a fraction more when that spend is necessary) then I will do so.
By paying a bill that doesn't exist? It's not rubbish and I don't agree that it's common sense.
And yes the topic of this thread is paying the tax bill to the ATO and earning points.
Yes, I agree that the ATO may be a bit pissed off at people wasting their time (as my understanding is that these refunds are a manual process). The other problem that you may run into is that under tax law income tax deductibility of the fees is directly linked to the payment itself (for businesses), i.e. the logic for allowing a deduction for the fee is that paying tax itself is a cost of doing business (and hence an allowable deduction). It would be hard to make a case that paying ATO then asking for a refund is a legitimate business expense if they were prompted to review your affairs.I think the issue is it's all well and good to be making these payments where you have an obligation and can make the occasional 'mistake' in over estimating your obligation.
Abuse of this e.g. PAYG taxpayers who've never needed to make these sorts of payments is only going to draw unwanted attention to it and increase restrictions for everyone. Much like certain retail staff getting their knickers in a knot about Visa GC buying. I'm sure we're all well intentioned on this forum but the authorities may start thinking of real or imagined threats which they'll need to impose restrictions on to combat.
I recall in this thread one member reported over paying their tax and the ATO called them on it then refunded the payment to the original source (notwithstanding they usually refund to linked bank account) which defeated the member's purpose of making the payment.
Your comment is rubbish for many. If it had been this would not be a post amongst the well over seven thousand in this thread.By paying a bill that doesn't exist? It's not rubbish and I don't agree that it's common sense. ....
Your comment is rubbish for many. If it had been this would not be a post amongst the well over seven thousand in this thread.
If I value a point at 2¢ and can get 10,000 points for an net cost of 1¢ each then I will do so as I am profiting in point value to the tune of $200 worth of points for $100.
Of course, if you don't burn / spend those points then they have no value.
Most people here do spend those points.
As indicated by Kangol, it's pre-paying.I think you have missed JohnK's point. He was talking about paying non existing bills as a desperate bid to generate points. I agree with him. His comment is not rubbish!
As indicated by Kangol, it's pre-paying.
Get's those points today for $100 as tomorrow they may cost $250 and the opportunity lost.
I do not see such action as "desperate"; merely being anticipatorily smart.
I got a land tax bill for OSR NSW due early september and wondering if payment can be made using those $100 GC from WW or Coles , if not what is the best Visa / MC option for those bill considering they are gov bodies i have ANZ Travel , Westpac Black Master Card
Are you really desperate for points? I wouldn't want the ATO questioning why I paid a bill when I didn't have a bill to pay. They may treat it as money laundering.
I think you may be confusing government agencies, its AUSTRAC who monitor this. Given the problem has with their own systems I cant see them being anything but grateful that money is paid whether required or not. They have a whole program trying to get people to pay, they are far more concerned about that.
I am not confusing government agencies. I would not want to be making regular payments to government agencies when I did not owe them money. Too many red flags everywhere.
But I think it is quite clear that desperate people seek desperate measures.
Am not sure what part you think is incorrect. The link you reference seems quite clear that Austrac is the regulator.Burmans, you're aren't fully correct in your assertion about AUSTRAC, as can be seen here: About AUSTRAC | Australian Transaction Reports and Analysis Centre (AUSTRAC).
Am not sure what part you think is incorrect. The link you reference seems quite clear that Austrac is the regulator.
"AUSTRAC is Australia's financial intelligence agency with regulatory responsibility for anti-money laundering and counter-terrorism financing."
However your comment seems to miss the point of the title of this thread "ATO (tax office) payments by credit card" as such your comment that "if they thought that cash was being used through the tax system, they would complete an AUSTRAC report on a taxpayer" seems irrelevant to the thread which is about payment by CC.
If we are going to be pedantic your statements that "They are concerned with suspicious cash transactions (above $10,000)" is also incorrect. This is only one of three type of transactions they care about, see Chapter 7 - AML/CTF reporting obligations | Australian Transaction Reports and Analysis Centre (AUSTRAC).
Not sure what you means by the 5 key sectors that report to AUSTRAC as I thought there were three (Financial Services, Bullion and Gambling) as per
http://www.austrac.gov.au/chapter-2-designated-services but always happy to be educated
[FONT=&]The businesses we regulate provide more than 70 designated services in five key sectors:[/FONT]
- financial services
- gambling
- bullion dealers
- remittance service providers
- cash dealers.
I guess that is one consideration for those that need to "pre pay" tax.I think the word you may be looking for is "pre paying"
I think you have missed my point but that's OK.Your comment is rubbish for many. If it had been this would not be a post amongst the well over seven thousand in this thread.
How would it look if someone was earning $50,000 pa and "pre paying" $100,000 tax? I think the tax office would have some sort of list where they refund money. I would not want to be on that list especially on a low income. Raises too many red flags. If on the other hand you are already paying tens of thousands or hundreds of thousands of dollars of GST or tax then you would think you were safe.I think you have missed JohnK's point. He was talking about paying non existing bills as a desperate bid to generate points. I agree with him. His comment is not rubbish!