I want to underline again the fact that I'm glad that QF has some presence here. Having said that, I feel like they are missing the point of engaging with their customers over social media, which is a conversation, not a press conference - not unlike the issue many have had with a certain other airline's more vocal proponents lately.
To their credit,
Red Roo has been trying, but not as hard when it comes to the tough questions. It's a shame because there actually is
some good news in amongst everything else in today's announcement, and a lot of difficult news that is reasonable and commercially sensible.
Generally Platinum members fly in the premium cabins more than anyone else and therefore the May changes (PY 25-50%, J 50-75% and First 50-100%) were designed to be of benefit to our Platinum members.
With due respect,
Red Roo, you came on here today promising nothing but the facts. This is a benefit for travelers in your premium cabins,
not your Platinum members. Platinum members may or may not fly regularly in premium cabins - to say that the benefit was 'designed for them' is the very definition of spin. Sure, the extra F lounges are relevant, as would be the confirmed upgrades (whenever they materialise). But this simply is not.
The 'fact' is that in the last two rounds of announcements, Silver, Gold, Premium and 'Platinum One' members have all received (somewhat) tangible service improvements. While there hasn't been a significant derogation to Platinum benefits (unlike the last round that took away Anytime Access which some - though, granted, not all - members considered to be quite significant) the net effect of these improvements to the other tiers is to reduce the incentive for Platinum members to maintain their status. Very few will be in the position to leap from 1200 SCs to 3600 SCs, while in the meantime the benefits of sticking to 600 SCs are more attractive. And why wouldn't you, when you get improved benefits for a smaller total spend with QF so long as you fly premium? The rest of your travel spend would simply be better spent on similarly premium (or otherwise) services with QF's competitors.
Take it as you will, but as far as the 'facts' go, QF needs to acknowledge that they have not delivered any improvements for Platinum members as a whole (or better yet, do something about it), while having taken away significant benefits in the past year and improved the position of almost every other tier.