I think it’s fair depending on which side of the ledger you’re on. Everyone get’s another year of whatever they already have. But not everyone had to fly the same amount to get that status.I feel for people that were within a few SC of attaining a higher tier but its complicated for QANTAS. If they gave all those the benefit of the doubt and grant them the status bump, wouldn't they equally be entitled to drop the status of those punters with an Apr-Jul anniversary that were nowhere near retaining their status? it's unfair to expect QF to do one without the other. I think essentially pressing the pause button and letting people have another crack next year is the fairest outcome for all.
I can imagine someone who earned 50 of the 600 SCs to retain gold and getting an extra year imagines it as fair.
Whereas the person who earned 690 of the 700 to earn gold thinks its unfair.