The jury is still out, without much flying over past 2 years my priorities have changed. This post may just turn into a long winded ramble and my opinion only. Reading through these posts and other threads there are those who will voice their opinions 'QF is at fault/ blame’ etc. but when I think back to some of the posts, I read prior to covid the QF call centre waiting times and general customer service has been an issue for a while. However, this has not been my experience (due to status) and getting through to QF pre or during Covid be it reservations or VIP/ SST was significantly easier than getting through to VA (WP) or SQ (*G) or any other carriers I was flying with. Based on my recent experience the VA call centre seems to be the easiest to get through too and resolve issues, QF is second and SQ third. As a side note I ditched QF in late 2010 in favour of VA however within 3 years was back with QF and from memory 2010/11 was also the time that VA rebranded and JB/VA seemed to go head-to-head with AJ/QF. Initially things were good with the new VA, prices where cheaper in Y and J and the service seemed better, QF must have realised this and seemed to up the ante, the QF prices fell and the overall service improved. Then VA and QF prices started to increase, the VA Y service dropped back and the VA 'snack' etc came into the mix.
The other reason I went back to QF was my international travel increased and QF just had better reach using QF metal or OW and I have a better understanding of the OW rules and partner rules be it limited to EK. The VA mix of partner agreements was something I just did not bother to look into other than my ability to earn points with SQ or lounge access with DL and to this day I am unsure if access to the Delta lounges was based on flying J, my VA number being in the booking, my AMEX platinum charge card and/or the free Priority Pass membership, we were allowed access and that is all that mattered.
All my flights during the past 2 years have been booked with points as if I needed to change or cancel it was easy and no requirement to have cash tied up in the bank of QF or VA. Our current international bookings have been booked on SQ (KF) and EK (QF) via points as these airlines seem to be working on consistent patterns without to many issues other than normal IRROPs.
Also the QF VIP team has been quite accommodating in dealing with some of my more unusual requests, the latest being for my parents (both NB) getting my Grandmother back to PER and happens to be older than QF and in her 103 years (104 in 13 days) has only travelled by air 5-6 times. As I made all the bookings on behalf of my parents I included Dad’s QFF number so he could see this booking. He did call me a few times concerned that he could see his booking but not my Mums or Nans, I informed him it would be OK and as their travel was in two bookings (linked) it would just work. After making these bookings I called the VIP team and arranged lounge access for all the NB flyers, the wheelchair (Nans) through security at the start and end points. When dad called me a few days back it was just to say ‘everything went as planned off without a hitch’.