Property: Sheraton Centre Toronto Hotel
Status: Gold
Dates: 29 Dec - 1 Jan
Booked: Guest Room 1 King w/ Nathan Phillips Square View
Received: "Club lounge access, Guest room, 1 King"... with no Club access (but still with the desired view on a high floor)
First impressions reasonably good - was able to check in several hours early, and advised to charge the highest speed Wi-Fi to the room and the charge would be waived (it was, without asking). Good central location. Porters too busy to assist on arrival, which would have been helpful with three suitcases, but we survived.
Wasn't told of my upgrade at check-in, and at first, I got excited when I saw the new room when I later opened the app in the room. I figured I'd probably be 'Bonvoyed' for lounge access with the upgrade (Hilton is generous in this respect, Marriott usually not), so called Guest Services to check if I actually had access. They took a moment and said that yes, we did. Hooray!
Went up to the lounge, denied entry, but told we can come in if we pay CAD $200, each, per night. Didn't care that I'd been told otherwise by their colleague, so I went down to the front desk to complain. Duty manager eventually extended us access for that day only, and only after I said point blank that ~"your staff lied to me and it's embarrassing to have been turned away at the door". It was nice to have a look at the lounge - a very impressive and recently renovated space (when I can't say the same about the room, which was fine but 'North America meh'). But, just about every drink in the lounge was chargeable to everyone - even tea and coffee, and they made a point of highlighting that to everyone who approached the bar. So yes, we could have paid CAD $400 for the privilege of being able to pay more for refreshments, LOL. Still, ordered 2 G&Ts which ended up costing just under CAD $30 including tax and tip.
Evening snacks in the lounge were trying to be premium but quite poor. They had meat-free sliders which were hard on the bottom from sitting in the serving pan for too long, and little cylinders of lobster pasta that had no noticeable pieces of lobster and just had a faint taste of it in the sauce. I'd have had a little more of the cheese and sweets after, but plates and cutlery were at a premium and hard to chase down.
Other impressions - the hotel ran out of umbrellas, because of course, it was raining. The lobby cafe also couldn't make a bagel at 11am "because the kitchen changes at 10:30", but they could still make other things like avo toast that use the same toaster. Righteo.
Overall, not impressed and would try the nearby Hilton or Shangri-La next time as I have status with those chains too. I'd booked the Nathan Phillips Square view as that's usually where the fireworks are, but they ended up being relocated to the harbour, visible only from the opposite side of the hotel. Fortunately, some of the locals weren't impressed and went and set off their own fireworks around the square, so we still got something of a show.