Hydroxychloroquine - What Goes On?

Renato1

Established Member
Joined
May 1, 2015
Posts
1,730
I like watching Fox News.

Last Monday, on his radio show, Hannity interviewed a Doctor in a New York hotspot. Doctor said, he treated 350 patients of his and 150 in another area with hydroxychloroquine, antibiotics and zinc sulfate . At that time, he had had none going to hospital and none dead.

Next day Hannity had another New York doctor on who was also treating his patients with hydroxychloroquine - he was more coy about citing facts and figures, but said his results from using the anti-malaria drug on patients were positive.

On Saturday, Tucker Carlson had another doctor on describing the nightmare in New York hospitals. The Doctor then stated that he was using the anti-malaria drug as a prophylactic.

And New York Governor Cuomo was procuring 750,000 doses of the malaria drug chloroquine; 70,000 doses of its derivative, hydroxychloroquine; and 10,000 doses of the antibiotic Zithromax.

After President Trump expressed optimism over the results that French doctors had gotten with the drugs, and he had ordered the FDA to fast track testing of hydroxychloroquine, the Governors of Nevada and Michigan then passed orders preventing their doctors from using hydroxychloroquine on their patients,

These reports sort of raised a lot of questions to me like -
Would it not be a simple statistical test to see if, on contracting the virus, the population of people currently taking the drug for Lupus and arthritis have a significantly lower hospitalisation and death rate than the general population?

Would it not be a simple statistical test to compare the hundreds already treated with the drugs after contracting the virus, to an equivalent number of people who contracted the virus a few weeks prior who weren't treated?

What's up with those State Governors banning its use? and

Is the drug useless, or are New Yorkers and people here and in other countries now dying needlessly?

Then, on The Bolt Report tonight, he reported that New York health workers are now on the anti-malaria drug.
And that France and Italy now allows it to be used in some cases.
And that our health workers will be starting a trial in three weeks.

So, is this some kind of Right Wing Conspiracy in presenting the information above?
Or, does a partial cure fo rthe epidemic exist, but it doesn't work for the public ......but it is good for health workers? (Kind of reminds me of our Face Mask discussion)

Any thoughts?
Regards,
Renato
 
What are the ethical considerations regarding anonymous online medical practitioners advocating novel, untested off label indications for old drugs with known toxicity?
 
Turn business expenses into Business Class! Process $10,000 through pay.com.au to score 20,000 bonus PayRewards Points and join 30k+ savvy business owners enjoying these benefits:

- Pay suppliers who don’t take Amex
- Max out credit card rewards—even on government payments
- Earn & Transfer PayRewards Points to 8+ top airline & hotel partners

AFF Supporters can remove this and all advertisements

What are the ethical considerations regarding anonymous online medical practitioners advocating novel, untested off label indications for old drugs with known toxicity?
Virtually everything you put in your mouth can be toxic.
People die from anaphylaxis eating nuts,strawberries shellfish.
I have seen a person die from drinking too much water-psychogenic polydipsia.

So drugs are no different.Hydroxychloroquine has been used for nearly 70 years so it's side effects are pretty well known.When using any drug at the very least the serious side effects should be discussed with the patient as well as what you might think could be achieved.
Remember side effects do not affect everyone who takes the drug.The vast majority of patients take hydroxychloroquine without any side effects.The commonest are not serious-taste and nausea etc.
The most serious side effect in numbers is retinopathy with series showing 11.5% of patients using it for over 16 years may get this so annual eye examinations need to be done.
Nearly 5 years ago a new recommendation was made to reduce the maximum dose to 5mg per KG.Using this level the incidence falls to ~ 1%.
.

Hydroxychloroquine is on the WHO list of essential medicines.
 
Another prospective which reflects views of some in this discussion.

 
Another prospective which reflects views of some in this discussion.


Clearly Lupus sufferers just need to consult Renato1 who would prescribe a bex and a good lie down.
 
It is simple - compare the first Doctor mentioned who has an entire population of size 500, which was treated with hydroxychoroquine, to that of another Doctor in the same area with similar type patients who has treated an equivalent number of patients without it - and compare the results.

Look for anything in the two populations that may skew the results and make the populations atypical (e.g. comparing affluent patients with one doctor to low socio-economic types with the other)
Regards,
Renato
The first group has a chronic serious illness, How do you correct for that in a healthy group? The underlying reason the first group is getting hydroxychoroquine can certainly skew the results.

No Trump did not say they cured Covid.He said he wanted them to be used now.The FDA approved the use for Covid for trials and Compassionate use on 19/3.
Also one person died after drinking fish tank cleaner which contains Quinine.Trump said nothing about Quinine.So he did not cause deaths.
Trump has also built a stockpile of Hydroxychloroquine-2 drug companies have donated 50 million tablets.

You also hear what you want to hear and take the things stated in the MSM as fact when they definitely are not always so.
No not quinine. The fish tank cleaner contained chloroquine phosphate.

chloroquine is name trump used.
 
No not quinine. The fish tank cleaner contained chloroquine phosphate.

chloroquine is name trump used.
He didn't say fish tank cleaner.for heaven's sake. You really don't believe that he caused the deaths.The media reported that fish tank cleaner contained the drug yet You aren't blaming them are you.
Please drop this ridiculous bias.
 
He didn't say fish tank cleaner.for heaven's sake. You really don't believe that he caused the deaths.The media reported that fish tank cleaner contained the drug yet You aren't blaming them are you.
Please drop this ridiculous bias.
I never said anything about naming fish tank cleaner.
Really not sure why you need to be obtuse, and hyperbolic in defending him.

I made a simple correction, Trump did not say Quinine, as you claimed. He said a chemical name, that matched the ingredients on the bottle. I think the bias here is with the person going off on a rant, on wrong information, to defend trump
 
We used Chloroquine for Malaria prevention in my Air Force days. We quickly learnt that it had some severe limitations.

It made the odd person sick (ie throw up) through to occasionally not working at all. My brother in law was flying a Caribou somewhere way north of Darwin when he collapsed at the controls and nearly died. He had developed Malaria despite the medication.
 
We used Chloroquine for Malaria prevention in my Air Force days. We quickly learnt that it had some severe limitations.

It made the odd person sick (ie throw up) through to occasionally not working at all. My brother in law was flying a Caribou somewhere way north of Darwin when he collapsed at the controls and nearly died. He had developed Malaria despite the medication.
I did read it was discontinued for malaria prevention as the bug became resistant. Goodness, I'm glad I don't get these side effects. It can affect the heart, can't it? That's interesting. The Rheumatologist always does a very thorough "heart" exam too.

Goodness, I need take a bex and lie down. (I'm not very forgiving at the moment; just a warning 😤)
 
Can you send me some Box please we are running low? 😂
Can you even buy bex these days? I shall have a try. I might tell the pharmacist to stop reserving me a bottle of plaquenil when it comes in and I will just take Bex instead. Might be fun filming the reaction
 
Nope, unfortunately. I remeber the boxes of bex at my grandmas place. Read the ingredients when much older and realised I'd missed out of some good stuff.
Do tell. What is in it then? I thought it was just a basic aspirin. Dammit, maybe Renato1 was on to a good thing?
 
Do tell. What is in it then? I thought it was just a basic aspirin. Dammit, maybe Renato1 was on to a good thing?
My memory says it was basically cocaine and speed and herion all in one. But that's not right, just that it was highly addictive. The yanks sell some good painkillers that include caffeine...

From some pharmac_ page:

Addiction to APC powders was common, with high rates of addiction in New South Wales and Queensland particularly.3 The dosages in Bex powder are one indication of the reason for its addictive qualities and its toxicity, with some formulations containing 420 mg of aspirin, 420 mg of phenacetin and 160 mg of caffeine in a single dose.4

And from Wikipedia Bex (compound analgesic) - Wikipedia

Bex was a strong compound analgesic which was popular in Australia for much of the twentieth century. It came in the form of APC (aspirinphenacetincaffeine) tablets or powder, containing 42% aspirin, 42% phenacetin, plus caffeine.[1]
 
Geez, I remember BEX - when I was a young girl ( a very long time ago ) my grandfather used to take a BEX with his cup of tea at 10am everyday - just in case he got a headache :rolleyes: It was a pretty pink powder !!

It was the phenacetin that was addictive and a kidney killer !
 
Geez, I remember BEX - when I was a young girl ( a very long time ago ) my grandfather used to take a BEX with his cup of tea at 10am everyday - just in case he got a headache :rolleyes: It was a pretty pink powder !!

It was the phenacetin that was addictive and a kidney killer !
Pink. I remember that. Clearly my granny used it. In a sweet little navy blue box.
 
My memory says it was basically cocaine and speed and herion all in one. But that's not right, just that it was highly addictive. The yanks sell some good painkillers that include caffeine...

From some pharmac_ page:

Addiction to APC powders was common, with high rates of addiction in New South Wales and Queensland particularly.3 The dosages in Bex powder are one indication of the reason for its addictive qualities and its toxicity, with some formulations containing 420 mg of aspirin, 420 mg of phenacetin and 160 mg of caffeine in a single dose.4

And from Wikipedia Bex (compound analgesic) - Wikipedia

Bex was a strong compound analgesic which was popular in Australia for much of the twentieth century. It came in the form of APC (aspirinphenacetincaffeine) tablets or powder, containing 42% aspirin, 42% phenacetin, plus caffeine.[1]
My dance teacher had a few too many Bex leading to a very long lie down. Renal failure I think, and premature death of someone otherwise so very fit (she had amazing energy on the dance floor).
 
Can you even buy bex these days? I shall have a try. I might tell the pharmacist to stop reserving me a bottle of plaquenil when it comes in and I will just take Bex instead. Might be fun filming the reaction
No, it was banned in 1977 because it contains the somewhat nasty phenacetin .

1585711268548.png
 

Become an AFF member!

Join Australian Frequent Flyer (AFF) for free and unlock insider tips, exclusive deals, and global meetups with 65,000+ frequent flyers.

AFF members can also access our Frequent Flyer Training courses, and upgrade to Fast-track your way to expert traveller status and unlock even more exclusive discounts!

AFF forum abbreviations

Wondering about Y, J or any of the other abbreviations used on our forum?

Check out our guide to common AFF acronyms & abbreviations.
Back
Top