I certainly didn't intend denying anyone the right to whinge. I suspect a good portion of my posts would be regarded by someone as a whinge, so can't really be too critical.
I guess for the infrequent traveller who specifically wants this benefit it would be very frustrating. I agree that QC membership for 3 or 4 flights a year seems a waste.
The more frequent travellers would be more tolerant I guess, hoping that the refurbs ultimately provide a better product (J lounge at least). That said, I've avoided the Melbourne lounges so far as I've not been travelling QF (domestic) or in general as much lately. The BNE lounges during the refurbs were not too pleasant while the work was happening.