This is just nuts. There isn't the manpower to vet awards and judge whether members are sufficiently deserving of good awards. Where awards unravel, it is easy to point to the specific conversation that caused it, and invariably it is an agent who deletes a ticketed sector before the replacement one is ticketed. Please can we stop with the conspiracy theories as they obscure the real issue which is that the staff in the overseas call centre lack the experience, training and systems to enable them to do what Hobart does.
Also worth bearing in mind that we are not typical members and our preferences - for the longest, most convoluted routes or seeking out specific planes, seat layouts and lounges - will seem counter-intuitive when most pax want convenience. Some of the old hands in Hobart will get it, but the newer agents overseas haven't seen enough of it yet to understand how much it matters to some of us.
And yes, there are some agents who are naughty and lie.