You are far too lenient on Qantas and its diaspora of customer service agents.
I didn't mention the agents or anything.
OK. Two things....
1. I got my situations a bit confused between the "WS" flight number on SEA-YYC trying to access a lounge there
and
2. LAX-YVR on QF codeshare (QF3356) flight on WS trying to get access to the International Business Lounge as QC members.
I was responding to, but did not quote,
@roslynm above - who was, I read back, situation 2.
Now, the response from QF, I now agree, was wrong because they were discussing oneworld rules, but mentioning QC members - the two are not really the same of course, and QC members have their own rules.
So, apologies for that mixup.. My bad.
My reading of the rules on both th QF/WS page and the QC lounge access policies allow for QC members lounge access on a QF flight number alone - irrelevant who operates it. This is consistent with AFF Editors' comments and as confirmed by QF to them, but not to whoever provided that response to
@roslynm
so yeah, I was unintentionally lenient on the agents by making it seem that I accepted the wrong advice. That's on me. I had conflated oneworld and QC membership criteria (and oneworld doesn't even come into it of course).
so. yep. mea culpa. apologies all round, but not to the person who gave that response with the incorrect, to my reading, info.
I kicked an own goal with my own gotchya. d'oh!