While there may be a significant number of people in this forum who would achieve status and then spend their travel budget with other airlines, I think there are a lot of other people who, having achieved the status, would continue to spend with QF to enjoy the benefits of the status. That is, after all, the whole point of the exercise.
Unless you regard status as a trophy. Again, there may be a significant number of people in this forum who do, but I suspect they are outnumbered outside fora such as this.
Of course and I agree.
My comment was based on thinking of a "generic" P1 (ie not someone going for status for the fact of having it, chasing eytc or pretty much a member of niche groups like this).. and so I still contend that if one is P1 they are unlikely to spend *MORE* (note more) based on a bonus offer because they're likely going to do it(retain) on their (or their company/business spend) anyway.
At P1 there's no real further incentive to achieve, and most P1 travel enough that the notion to spend more to fly more is probably not high on the list
Now sure, i suppose the idea of LTP is now an incentive but honestly even for high SC earns that achieve P1 you're still looking at ~20 years of P1 qualification to get there. That's a LOT!!! Sure, there are people on this forum who earn well over this - say 7k, 9k SC a year - but at those levels of earn again you spend a coughload anyway, get the benefits and probably could care less about LTP
Anyway again this is why I understand QF not offering bonus SC offers (until now, apparently!
) to P1 because it's more likely than not that they will not make incremental income from the effort - maybe a little bit. Certainly status chasers or those using them to GET to P1, and a few of us who would really need DSC to retain it (I can't see myself retaining P1 next year tbh) but again people who care about such things are a minority in the general QF landscape, and likely small even in the pretty small population of P1's (that seems to be under 10k members and some say around 5k).
Just my opinion. Obviously I don't know and have no inside knowledge.
.. and QF of course has proven me wrong by sending this current targeted promo to *some* P1's which frankly surprises me, but I'm happy for them if they can use it