Thinking about this some more;
As gold i was spending between $4,000 to $6,000 a year to keep Gold status; mix of economy and business, so maybe I don't fly that much so Qantas don't think I am not that important.
If you are Platinum this really sucks.
To be platinum as a mostly domestic passenger is really going to hurt.
You might be flying trunk routes and sometimes you can get row 4 but other times you could only get exit row, 20 SCs x 60 flights to get the 1200SCs that is a lot of flying in economy, so if you don't get row 4 often you will be in row 5 or 6.
Thinking about it a regular flyer as a Gold will probably feel just as bad, maybe you fly every 2nd week and so can't even get row 4 so you will always be stuck in row 5, or 6.
I think I go and fly Virgin for a bit Economy X with lounge, thanks Qantas for letting me try something else.