I completely agree - Golds should not be punished for being organised. Golds may not fly every week, but fly often enough that they have a fairly organised procedure for arriving at the airport, and getting there 2 hours before check-in just to try and get Row 3/4/5 is not part of that procedure. I have a pretty smooth process for flying now and dont want to be held up by once-a-year morons that get to the airport 2 hours before their flight and are now seated in front of me.
I would have thought a fair and obvious system would be:
T-14 days - WP can select 3-5, SG can select 6 and back etc
T-48 hours when OCLI opens - WP and SG can both select rows 3 and back
At the airport - anyone can ask for whatever they want.
I find it very hard to believe there are 24 WPs/WP guests on each flight.