If you can rationalise paying a much higher surcharge for the exact same points earning, you might want to think about how you play the game.
The comments are specific to the product mentioned, which earns 1:1. There are still a few Visa/MC options that do the same.
My current card for ATO is the CBA Platinum Amex, and as we all know is being axed from ATO points earning in a months time. So I was looking for alternatives for myself and I've been rejected a couple times from ANZ, so it's gonna be very hard for me to ever get the ANZ Black. So I've given up on them, for myself that is, but I'll get the missus to apply when she can in the near future. Completely forgot about this card as I've dismissed it for myself and somehow dismissed it for the missus as well for some reason.
My preferred FF is SQ, and there aren't many SQ earning credit cards around for ATO. Just the AMEX's, ANZ Blacks, Westpac Black/Krisflyer (no more new applications) and soon to cease CBA cards. I think these are all that's left for SQ earn, please correct me if I'm wrong.
I understand what you are saying. Paying $1/pt @ 1.42% and then transferring to SQ at 1.35VA:1KF (1VA:0.74KF) is a coughpy way to earn SQ. Westpac Black is in the same boat, at 0.75 ff miles/$ on the Amex. ANZ amex is 1KF/$ (0.66KF/$ on the Visa) so is the best card for transfers to SQ.
If using the ANZ black card:
A return SQ J flight to SEA is roughly 110,000 miles = $110,000 spend on AMEX ($1562 surcharge) or $166,666 on VISA ($700 surcharge). I'm just saying for some people who don't have much spend, and would like to get that J flight quicker, can justify paying $1500 in surcharge to get those J seats, which are roughly valued at $4000 or so. Also, given you can deduct 30% of the surcharge, that's a $1050 surcharge (likewise for the VISA $490 surcharge) otherwise that $450 would have gone to the ATO as Tax and not as a surcharge.
Obviously if you're ATO spend is nearing or over 7-figures, then you wouldn't need to use the Amex, but if you're annual spend is only $100k, then that's an extra 1 year of using the visa card to get the same J flight. Depends how desperate you are for the points I guess.
Please let me know if any of the figures/calculations are incorrect as this will obviously affect how I calculate points.