I have an aversion to losing shiny wallet candy, but looks like my VA WP days are over (shame i've re-qualified through end of August 2017 already).
Seems to be a case of adopting a mix of NZ's fare structure and USA airlines pay-for-everything-and-call-ourselves-a-full-service-airline methods.
I had a simple plan when I reach LTG in a few weeks (been planning for 18 months or so); Move all domestic to VA (had already done that) and all international to AA and build up points there.
Then, EY awards jumped in points and MASSIVE surcharges were applied (from the VA side). AA did the 'if you can't beat them, join them' and followed the race-to-the-bottom of the USA FF programs and made it revenue based with mostly terrible partner earn (% of fare for EQD's on partner airlines etc).
Whilst QF may have shocking fuel fines, VA have joined QF in the lack of availability stakes for premium cabin redemptions on long haul routes.
So I guess i'll use my four free upgrades when my next year rolls over, and then burn my remaining VA miles (burned 200k or so earlier in the year on EY flights) and have to grumble and go back to QF. At least earning QF points is very simple.
So long, VA. I may have not been the worlds biggest WP spender, but the combined employer and personal spend around the 5 digit mark is going to other airlines, most probably QF.