I just can't see the point of getting on early ? You are on the plane for a long time and I bet most people can't wait to get off so why race to get onboard ? The FAs will find a place for your carry on, your seat is guaranteed, I just don't understand this whole priority boarding concept. For me, late boarding would be great.
Having said that, I'm usually in cattle class, maybe in J or above you get time for a glass of champers but why not just stay in the lounge and have that while the masses are boarding ?
Its subtle, thats for sure. Also without doubt subjective. But for me, it matters. I've had quite the chance to use DJ's version and I must say that I understand why its a good thing when it works and when you can pretty much count on it.
Subjectively then:
1) I hear the boarding call and the urge to go to the gate takes over. I've been trying lately to fight the urge and stay longer in the lounge, but the urge is so strong that I don't enjoy my last few minutes in the lounge. I think this feeling relates to the possibility of being too smart by half and getting locked out. Irrational I know, but there it is.
2) Given point #1, surely not many folk enjoy milling around the scrummage which is the gate area a few moment/minutes after the first boarding call? I leave the lounge, go to the gate. The area is full. Standing room only ... no point lining up in a line thats already spilling out into the common area. So, stand and wait? Its not fun.
3) With PB, I don't have to fight the irrational lounge fear, I can leave the lounge when boarding is called. Go to the thronging gate and, usually, leave that rather unpleasant area with a minute or two.
4) I've been lucky I admit, can't remember ever having been stuck in the aero bridge with more than 2-3 folks in front of me. So, within say 5 minutes of leaving the lounge I'm in my comfy chair, and yes, if the crew are up to the job I'm quite possibly already sipping a chardy and looking at the paper
I'm happy to contribute part of the ticket cost to this little thing. Along with the aforementioned Chardonnay, newspaper, something to eat, a movie and the (hopefully) comfy chair, the whole end-to-end package can making flying if not 100% enjoyable surely less abhorrent.