casanovawa
Established Member
- Joined
- Jan 17, 2011
- Posts
- 2,973
Yeah, moving the last part of this discussion to a new thread has its merits..
We are considering how to earn DM miles at around rates of $1 per mile because these are incidental miles over and above whatever we have actually spent our money on (fuel/movie tickets/etc)... Yes you can buy DM miles at a much better rate directly during bonus promotions, but you only get the miles themselves, the credit card spend is obviously for bonus miles for topping/speeding up and at around the $1 per mile (or $1 per 0.6 DM mile) rate is not that far off the same rate for QF or KF earning... It is lower than QF but obviously in wokring out the package you look at the earn and the burn plus taxes rate and for QF it catches up on the burn/taxes side of the equation but its sounds perhaps like KF might come out ahead overall... AA could be another goer although I haven't looked at that so much recently although on buying their award points alone I think DM stacks up better...
What I also like about DM is the option at least i have heard of (haven't booked one yet) of getting a flight to your designated continental zone or destination and then, as long as its not an open jaw, a stop over in another one (so ineffect a return flight plus a second flight to another location on the one redemption) which i don't think you get with QF redemptions and AA award flights are one way point to point aren't they... That might not be much of a selling point to another person though...
One obvious advantage is if people are thinking of using DM miles program from time to time, the fewer programs you are earning points/miles with the better and the sooner you will qualify for rewards... If you are buying DM miles periodically, transferring Amex MR points to KF and earning QF points at Woolies etc you are splitting your earnings across several programs which maybe necessary, but is hardly the most efficient... Adding AAvantage would be a 4th program...
I originally just put the calculations out there just to see if there is anyway on a $ for $ basis of earn and then redemption DM could in anyway be justified even with the convoluted route you would need to take advantage of it... It probably does but not sufficiently for me I guess... I have never really used KF and have no cards that convert that way so have little experience in that either...
We are considering how to earn DM miles at around rates of $1 per mile because these are incidental miles over and above whatever we have actually spent our money on (fuel/movie tickets/etc)... Yes you can buy DM miles at a much better rate directly during bonus promotions, but you only get the miles themselves, the credit card spend is obviously for bonus miles for topping/speeding up and at around the $1 per mile (or $1 per 0.6 DM mile) rate is not that far off the same rate for QF or KF earning... It is lower than QF but obviously in wokring out the package you look at the earn and the burn plus taxes rate and for QF it catches up on the burn/taxes side of the equation but its sounds perhaps like KF might come out ahead overall... AA could be another goer although I haven't looked at that so much recently although on buying their award points alone I think DM stacks up better...
What I also like about DM is the option at least i have heard of (haven't booked one yet) of getting a flight to your designated continental zone or destination and then, as long as its not an open jaw, a stop over in another one (so ineffect a return flight plus a second flight to another location on the one redemption) which i don't think you get with QF redemptions and AA award flights are one way point to point aren't they... That might not be much of a selling point to another person though...
One obvious advantage is if people are thinking of using DM miles program from time to time, the fewer programs you are earning points/miles with the better and the sooner you will qualify for rewards... If you are buying DM miles periodically, transferring Amex MR points to KF and earning QF points at Woolies etc you are splitting your earnings across several programs which maybe necessary, but is hardly the most efficient... Adding AAvantage would be a 4th program...
I originally just put the calculations out there just to see if there is anyway on a $ for $ basis of earn and then redemption DM could in anyway be justified even with the convoluted route you would need to take advantage of it... It probably does but not sufficiently for me I guess... I have never really used KF and have no cards that convert that way so have little experience in that either...