How do Hilton treat you as an Elite?

Status: Diamond
Property: Hilton Surfers Paradise
Date:
Stay 1 - 25/27 December 2012
Stay 2 - 6 January 2013
Rate:
Stay 1 - $454.90/nite - Early Special Rate
Stay 2 - $132.50 Thank you rate.
Booked:
Stay 1 - 3 bedroom residence, high floor, ocean view
Stay 2 - Hilton accessible room
Received:
Stay 1 - 3 Bedroom residence, low floor (10), ocean view
Stay 2 - 1 Bedroom residence mid level (24) hinterland view

They got right:
Stay 1 - booked for 2 A, 2C but later realised I should have booked for more (just in case) as the "early Special Rate" included exec. lounge access and full breakfasts for all guests. HH central reservations wanted an additional $60 per person to do this, whereas the in-house team altered the reservation to 5 A + 2 C, no charge due to my diamond status. Ended up with 4A + 2C staying.

Stay 2 - At my request, upgraded to a 1 bedroom residence as four of us wanted to stay. Nice room, not bad floor and great for a (requested) upgrade at a chockers hotel.

They got wrong:
Stay 1 - Low floor Boulvard tower which I actually class as a downgrade from what was ordered. 3 bedroom appartments in the Boulevard tower are much smaller than the 3 bedroom apartments in the Orchid tower. Had to wait until 5.00pm for check-in because a diamond wouldn't vacate (apparantly). Sent to exec. lounge to wait for two hours which borders on ridiculous. Lifts a night mare. Evening canapes boring (bordering on "why bother").

Stay 2 - No robes, no water, no pen, no milk, not enough towels, no slippers. Ordered collectively and delivered spasmodically after reminder calls. Each call (four in total) to magic was answered by the same charming lady so I'm beginning to wonder if there is only 1 person on the switch?????? That would certainly explain the extensive wait times on hold. Canapes still the same boring rubbish so I enjoyed the remainder of the complementary wine from the Hilton BNE on my balcony instead. Breakfast this morning was woeful (according to my usually upbeat wife) and flys in the face of past breakfasts in Salt, which usually are great. Luckily I had work to attend to so I missed it. I hope that was a once off bad morning and it's not a trend developing for the worse. Attempted to charge for "high speed internet" on the bill.

Summary: As discussed elsewhere, HSP is certainly struggling with the basics and both the hotel itself, as well as the staff simply cannot handle a full hotel. They have excelled with things like upgrades (at least in my experience) and some of the staff are really responsive and excellent at what they do, but the way-too-many issues now make this a hotel I'll be avoiding. Waiting 15-20 minutes (and longer) for a lift while cleaners fill them with their trolleys is depressing. The exec. lounge has a nice view but a terrible selection which never alternates (also, someone needs to advise HSP what a canape actually is). Soup, rice and jelly beans don't cut it with me, the cheese board is nearly always out of cheese or crackers or both and not everyone likes antipasto. They regularly run out of plates, glasses and paper serviettes and the drinks fridge is the size of a thimble and staff rarely bother to look in to see what needs replenishing.

Recommend: Probably not. I've just cancelled two future bookings as a stay at HSP has become something to dread, not enjoy. Hopefully they'll get some help in to sort out what the current management can't do.​
 
Status: Diamond
Property: Hilton Surfers Paradise

Sounds like HSP is a very hit and miss property. I know that new properties can be wet behind the ears, so to speak, but when HSW started it was straight out of the blocks (IME) and doing quite well.

I hope it's got nothing to do with the seemingly more 'relaxed' attitude on the Gold Coast. Hilton is quite a premium brand - yes the HSP decor and feel may had been intended to be a bit more relaxed but the service needs to be a minimum standard.

That said, bar a couple on the top of my head (Q1 possibly comes to mind), is there a better property on the Gold Coast? By the time one thinks about it, you may as well stay at the cheapest property that you're happiest with, chain hotel or not. Perhaps Hilton (or rather, the property management) are relying on this to some degree.
 
I have seen it 6pm to whenever the last one leaves, once 9:15pm last year (drinks remained complimentary). [and, no, it was not an AFF do ...]

YMMV on this.
I have seen that also but since the change of management/staff they seem to stick to an 8:00pm shutdown.
 
Status: Diamond
Property: Hilton South Wharf Melbourne
Date: 7th Jan 2013 (1 night)
Booked: Standard room.
Received: Executive Room on 17th floor.

I was initially upgrade to one of the suites as i checked before i left MEL airport. i was told no only executive room available for me despite the suites were still available to purchase later that night. my DM card were presented at check-in.

i got the impression any non-caucasian will NEVER get suite upgrade at this property. i asked the guy wether any suite were available he said no, i told him i was upgraded when i last checked my booking. the rate i paid was Point + cash where points is also coming from a DM member but with a caucasian last name.

it feels like the original assigned suite was set up for me but the check-in agent decided to sent me to another room with the following.

no card,
no welcome amenity,
no turndown service
absolutely nothing apart from 2 bottles of water delivered later.

strictly 1pm check-out, no later.
ask wether i can use the executive lounge after check-out, the agent took a look at her computer and said ok, as long as nothing is consumed and coded a card for me.
the phone rang at night time asking me how was my stay and a few questions saying since its my first time/stay here (which is not, both of us have booked once during 2012 under our own name) she would like to make some notes / personal preferences for my future stays. She also ask about wether i'd rather have room upgrade + breakfast OR 1000 points next time? (DMs gets both) She clearly doesn't know the HH rules.

all the staff were polite but fairly strict, they would not change their mind once they said something to you despite i have always asked very nicely and politely. good to see the staff at the executive lounge were slightly more flexible and made my stay more welcoming.
 
That's quite disappointing - I find the check in team very helpful - although did only get upgraded to an Exec room rather than a suite recently for the first time...
 
I've given up on HHon, it started becoming hard work to get the bookings right and gave up completely doing it on line as web site errors wouldn't let me complete a booking. The most recent a week back when I got a discount promo email from them and the link didn't work so they don't want me that badly I guess.

But, having said that I now stay and not bother with their loyalty program and the sense of frustration is now gone. :D Stayed at South Wharf over the weekend and service was fine, although they couldn't find any bubble bath for my 2 yo although a few months earlier the front desk was falling over itself to give me some without asking.

So I'll still stay at Hilton's but they have lost me as a loyalty customer and will try out a few other places.

My next Hilton stay is a week in Boise Idaho next month.

matt
 
Status: Gold
Property: Hilton Brisbane
Date: 5th-7th Jan 2013 for 2 nights
Rate: $ 88 - Thank you Rate, 2 Adults
Booked: Standard Guest Room
Received: King Hilton Suite :lol: on 25th Floor

- Arrived at 7AM, checked in straight away.
- GM's welcome card, bottle of red, two bottles of water,
- Bvlgari Guest Collection Hotel Amenities Gift Set
- Turn down service provided with extra bottles of water & bed side tea
- 4pm late checkout requested and granted on last day

Executive Lounge was still closed for "renovations" ( they've removed the ladder and put painters rags down now instead, no paint tins or brushes to be seen anywhere ), breakfast / refreshment / drinks&canapés vouchers were provided at alternate location at level 6 vintaged bar.

IMAG0792.JPGIMAG0824.jpgIMAG0810.jpg
 
Last edited:
Is there any rhyme or reason why people get bottles of wine? I never get one - here. I recall getting them in China though.
 
i got the impression any non-caucasian will NEVER get suite upgrade at this property. i asked the guy wether any suite were available he said no, i told him i was upgraded when i last checked my booking. the rate i paid was Point + cash where points is also coming from a DM member but with a caucasian last name.

I really really hope this is not the case. I've never had a suite upgrade, and I have a caucasian name and am caucasian, and I've stayed at HSW any number of times. I reckon the GM must have changed in 2012 as service levels slipped noticeably and dramatically.
 
I really really hope this is not the case. I've never had a suite upgrade, and I have a caucasian name and am caucasian, and I've stayed at HSW any number of times. I reckon the GM must have changed in 2012 as service levels slipped noticeably and dramatically.

Straitman has recently mentioned the change of management, being one of the regulars at HSW.
 
Status: Gold
Property: Hilton Brisbane
Date: 5th-7th Jan 2013 for 2 nights
Rate: $ 88 - Thank you Rate, 2 Adults
Booked: Standard Guest Room
Received: King Hilton Suite :lol: on 25th Floor

- Arrived at 7AM, checked in straight away.
- GM's welcome card, bottle of red, two bottles of water,
- Bvlgari Guest Collection Hotel Amenities Gift Set
- Turn down service provided with extra bottles of water & bed side tea
- 4pm late checkout requested and granted on last day

Executive Lounge was still closed for "renovations" ( they've removed the ladder and put painters rags down now instead, no paint tins or brushes to be seen anywhere ), breakfast / refreshment / drinks&canapés vouchers were provided at alternate location at level 6 vintaged bar.

View attachment 12407View attachment 12408View attachment 12409

Was the 'view' of the bathroom able to be disappeared? It's an extremely rare occurrence but I have been known to share a bed with a member of the opposite sex who I am in a strictly platonic relationship with. Not sure they would be entirely comfortable with that 'view' being permanent (though I doubt it would bother me :oops:)

Is there any rhyme or reason why people get bottles of wine? I never get one - here. I recall getting them in China though.

Got one in my one and only stay at Hilton SYD last year (and that is the only time I have received one). Nice gesture and appreciated, but unfortunately due to 1) I already had a nice shiraz in the room and 2) the complimentary bottle was labelled shiraz but the colour of a light pinot noir and 3) I was returning to MEL on JQi with just hand luggage, it remained unopened. I probably should have taken it with me and dumped it, as they may have marked my file "does not like free wine" :shock:

I really really hope this is not the case. I've never had a suite upgrade, and I have a caucasian name and am caucasian, and I've stayed at HSW any number of times. I reckon the GM must have changed in 2012 as service levels slipped noticeably and dramatically.

Was the GM's name previously someone Christ? Perhaps they have lost their religion. I am 2 out of 2 for suite upgrades at HSW as a Diamond (1 x Yarra, 1 x Relaxation). I think there is a fair amount of luck involved as to the occupancy rate, and I have had zqsn5678's experience of having a suite appear in my booking, and receiving a lesser upgrade on arrival, but at Parmelia PER, and it was showing suite the night before - not necessarily 30 minutes prior to checkin. Seems like they process upgrades the day/night before, but you could still be gazumped afterwards by someone who is wiling to pay $$$ for a suite, though I can't explain the fact that suites were still available after his/her checkin. (Am Caucasian BTW)
 
Read our AFF credit card guides and start earning more points now.

AFF Supporters can remove this and all advertisements

Was the GM's name previously someone Christ? Perhaps they have lost their religion.

All my best stays at HSW were with Brett Christ at the helm. A reply a few posts above are indicating he's moved on. I stopped getting GM's notes a bit after mid last year, so I no longer know who's running the show, but given anecdotal evidence here, I'd say Brett moved on around about then.
 

Become an AFF member!

Join Australian Frequent Flyer (AFF) for free and unlock insider tips, exclusive deals, and global meetups with 65,000+ frequent flyers.

AFF members can also access our Frequent Flyer Training courses, and upgrade to Fast-track your way to expert traveller status and unlock even more exclusive discounts!

AFF forum abbreviations

Wondering about Y, J or any of the other abbreviations used on our forum?

Check out our guide to common AFF acronyms & abbreviations.
Back
Top