I really don't need to list the issues that VA have at the moment with the implementation of new/improved products
Priority boarding has worked about 29 time out of 30 i've witnessed it in action.
Any time access seems hassle free - i'm sitting the VA lounge right now waiting for my JQ flight.
My free platinum upgrades work fine.
Fly ahead has been offered to me on every occasion where there has been a vacant seat and has saved me a small fortune by allowing me to book late evening return flights and swap them for earlier ones.
My 5 or so experiences of J domestic have been flawless (YMMV and obviously has and i'm not disputing that).
I personally think the renovated lounge in Melbourne is a massive improvement over the earlier version.
Kerb side lounge access in Sydney is working fantastically well and i greatly appreciate it.
I am now enjoying HHonors Diamond and extracting a hell of a lot of value of it.
I get a preallocated aisle seat in the first two rows of Y every time i fly (except when i book late or am swapped to an early flight by choice).
In the event of Irrops i am consistently contact in advance (if they are aware in advance) and looked after at the airport if they are not.
The enthusiasm professionalism of the flight crew is evident on most if not all flights i have taken.
The routes i look at are still mostly cheaper and generally comparable to QF - although there are always exceptions.
The generous bonus points i get as a platinum FF (mixed with come CC spend) have allowed me to accrue enough for annual international J class trips for our family of 3 for the last two years.
My partner has found her partner gold status soon to be partner platinum quite valuable.
OTOH... Yes, there are catering issues in J at the moment (i haven't experienced them but they are clearly valid), Aircraft subs are causing issues for a small but significant number of J passengers, the IFE is generally going backwards for the time being and this disappoints me. On the whole the positives are much more than the negatives.
It's particularly ironic to be complaining in the context of the OOL Lounge thread. You might want to ask some Qantas Club members who use OOL a lot for their perceptions of how Virgin are tracking there. Virgin may not be able to tell you the date the lounge will open but i'd imagine Qantas Club members can tell you when the lounge closed and QF dumed the place entirely.