I have 3 Coles stores within a 10 minute walk, and the nearest Safeway/Woolworths is a 10 minute drive.
10 mins drive? So it would be very easy (and free) for you to get an EDR card, and use it just occasionally. The same is true for the vast majority of people in Oz. Of course everyone is free to choose not to avail of this opportunity, or any of the numerous other QFF points earning opportunities, but people who make that choice are IMHO unlikely to get much sympathy if their points expire as a result.
The OP and another poster clearly made a mistake or an oversight in not checking the T&C's. Should they be punished to the tune of 400k FF points. I dont think so.
Actually both of these members appear to have been aware of the way things work, with expiry after 18 months of no activity, so it has nothing to do with them not checking the T&Cs.
It was the other poster that said he lost 400k points, and he openly admits that he received and read the e-mail from Qantas warning him that his points were going to expire, and explaining what he needs to do to prevent that happening. What more do you want Qantas to have done in that case?
The OP in this thread, as far as I can see, has not divulged how many points he lost, despite being asked. So we really don't know to what extent he has been "punished". What we do know is that he previously found himself in the same situation, but avoided losing his points on that occasion by making a purchase from the rewards store. So again, it's clear he understood how the programme works, his issue seems to be that he did not know when the 18 months were up this time round. He alleges that Qantas try to keep that information hidden, but as previously pointed out, that is not the case. All you have to do is check your activity statement and you will see your last activity date appears in bold at the top of the page. It is unfortunate if he didn't receive an e-mail reminder in addition to that, but obviously we don't know if he has kept his details up to date with QFF etc. In any case, trying to keep points active in an FF program in which you earn no points ever, and which is based in a foreign country, is likely to require some effort. I've certainly lost points in similar circumstances, and have no complaints about it.