Yes indeed each to their own. I will see how a second bottle goes before I fully commit to final opinion. Being a highly rated vintage I think i will be able to offload in the years to come if I wish. I'll store it away and try another bottle in a few years and who knows.
With all respect, won't go near GWD attitude will not get you very far if that attitude also carries across to other discount sites. I try and buy wine from everywhere; Cellar Door, Auction, Epiqure, Vinomofo, GWD, Distributors, Liquidators and Retail. I fully understand your reservations but buying one bottle of a few things can help you find something outstanding such as the 2008 FU Shiraz. Of course some of the other things I have tried along the way from GWD in coming across this are average. Current example of that is the 2011 Viking Shiraz which does not stack up against the 2010 Viking Shiraz. The Viking Shiraz grapes used to go into Grange. GWD has a few current wines that have won trophies in international shows, not medals but trophies, one being a Luchador Inferno Cab Sauv for a budget sapping $9.99 (12 bottle buy) that again shames the Seppelt Moyston a lot of us bought in an Epiqure special deal and also a lot of other Cab Sauv's I have drunk recently. Ignore at your own peril I say. Even one of my St Henri vintages I picked up at $45 a bottle from a discount site that Penfold's (TWE) supposdely don't do.