OK I'll only address the point I was trying to make one more time
I do NOT disagree with the comments above regarding other options (I thought I was clear on that, apparently not
).
We (as a group of more experienced/savvy/interested flyers) know there are more options. We also have a fair idea of things like alliances, earn rates, product differences (eg who has the best lounges, the stopover benefits, the onboard hard/product, etc) and we will also pick our routes and options based on way more than most "average" people would - from FF earning goals, to trying a new product, to enjoying a stopover in say The Pier F lounge or Cabanas at HKG. Sometimes it may even be to fly on a specific aircraft type - maybe because we prefer it, or to try it because it's new and shiny.
I can guarantee that the vast majority of flyers have far more simple requirements - no matter the cabin:
I would guestimate (since it's foolish to suggest everyone is the same) these requirements would be a mix of:
- schedule
- price
- carrier (eg: "I only fly X airline" - for whatever reason)
- FF loyalty
- intangible (things like prior experience.. like the food sucked last time I flew that cheap flight on airline Y or they lost our bags)
I have zero issue with suggesting to folks that there are options out there, specially if they are lower priced... that's great. That's what travel agents , and systems like skyscanner etc do or we as the more experienced can potentially assist/advice others out there.
Not everyone has a resident AFF member or bothers to use a travel agent or other tool to check prices or options. Some do. Or like the example above say "I'm not flying THAT airline" for some reason or other. I know a bloke who would refuse to even transit places like SIN/KUL and anywhere in the ME3 because he was against the governments of those countries. People make theiir choices for all kinds of reasons - and that's their right, even if it may seem silly to some others, or even wasteful. Many Ansett loyalists refuse to ever fly NZ for example, after the death of AN.
And as for advice or trying to help others out. I have a perfect example from just a few days ago.
I have a friend who travels a bit (is QF Gold) and received the DSC offer. She messaged me saying she had a trip to OOL coming up and she wanted to take advantage of that. So I said to her well that's great, just make sure it's a QF flight number. She came back and said to me oh but they're all Jetstar, the only QF for her dates was via SYD. I said to her well the QF product is likely to be a little nicer, and the extra stop will give you more SC which helps when doubled under the promo..... all reasonably sensible advice given the context I would think.
What did she do? She booked JQ... with points!
so... yeah!
anyway all of this discussion is way OT to QF changing it's flying to go via SIN etc.
issues about price, sales or not, perceived value to one person or another detract from the point I was trying to make that the PE product as a whole, not just QF but any carrier that offer it, is attractive to a certain market sector, and one that clearly is growing because airlines are adding PE cabins more than, for example, F. And just because I or someone else might only value a particular cabin product at a certain level, that doesn't mean the next flyer will.
Anyway I'm done on this issue
I'll finish with an ON topic comment.. QF have launched a J/F sale valid Mar-Aug next year at $6999/$9999 and, interestingly, includes EK coded flights which seems like quite nice details for those with the cash and plans for next year...