Was on Skype to USDM for nearly 3 hours yesterday. I was checking to see if HKG-YVR direct had opened up instead of my booked HKG-JFK-YVR, and noticed that there were J awards available SYD-YVR. So I jumped on line & called to change my outgoing flights from PER x HKG x JFK x YVR to MEL x SYD x YVR. I had separate flights booked MEL-PER & ret & was planning to drop these. Initially looked good - agent could see availability I fed to her & she sent them to the rates desk. It was taking a long time for her to come back & she finally returned to say that the rates desk had to price them manually and would take a bit longer. I also asked her if I could add PER-MEL onto the return. Next time she came back she said that they had noticed my MEL-PER booking & I told her that I would be cancelling that & was advised that it would be another US$150 each to re-deposit these miles which I was OK with. The next time she came back she said that there was a problem & that my original bookings were illegal (which I sort of knew anyway), and that they were looking at all options but couldn't see any alternatives. A bit later she came back with a flight PER-SYD to connect with the SYD-YVR - I tried to tell her that having an open jaw at the origin was legal, but in the end decided it was easier to go with the flow and leave my original MEL-PER booking in place & a day in Perth (the SYD-YVR flight is 2 days later than the original, but still gets into YVR on the same date, only 9 hours or so later, but at a more reasonable time anyway). With all this, they had lost one of our seats on the way back. More waiting while they tried to contact CX to try and get it re-instated, but she finally came back to say that the CX office they needed to contact was closed. She has a note to check if it is sorted when she has her next shift on Monday, and her supervisor is supposed to be following it up as well. The upshot is that they waived the $150 change fee, but I still haven't got the QF PNRs & Saudia is still showing the original flights, so it looks like the ticket hasn't been re-issued or whatever they have to do. I do have the CX PNRs so can see that the +1 still has her original seats, but I am wait listed for the HKG-PER leg.
I'm not prepared to HUACA and try to get either the open jaw or better still the start and end at MEL as I think the illegal bit is the YVR x JFK x HKG leg which looks like a significant backtrack to me.