Not just me. It is logical that you are a Qantas Platinum in the eyes of Qantas staff. A Oneworld Emerald is anyone with that tier from other Oneworld airlines. If Qantas didn’t want to distinguish between the 2 there wouldn't be this wording in the rules.
It may be 'logical' to you, but there is nothing to back this claim. And there needs to be separate wording for QF status and OW status entitlements because there are situations where you can have QF status but not OW and vice versa.
Your interpretation is slightly flawed. You can't be a Oneworld Emerald when flying Qantas and a Qantas Platinum when flying Jetstar. You are one or the other not either when it suits you. Obviously a Oneworld Emerald flying Jetstar has no access to First lounge?.
Under strict interpretation of the QF and OW rules as stated, you are both QF WP and OWE when flying QF metal, but only QF WP when flying Jetstar. I agree a non-QF OWE has no access the First lounge when flying Jetstar (even on a QF codeshare). It is your assumption that the 2 schemes are mutually exclusive, but I have not seen any evidence to back this.
Aldo don't take everything you hear from call centre staff as gospel. Most times I know more than they do and I am sure I am not the only person here on AFF in that situation. Many call centre staff have thanked me for bringing them up to date with things they did not know.
Anyway hope that Red Roo can respond to finally clarify the interpretation in your eyes.
I agree. But what I was told was explained in a rationale manner with specific examples outlined and is in keeping with the rules as stated so I choose to believe him.